Once upon a time, there was a little Web 2.0 application called Facebook. It came out way back in April 2004 -- I know that, only because I think I was one of the first Northwestern kiddies to sign up for the Myspace look-alike. At least, I should be, as I'm a proud member of my alma mater's "Facebook member since the ground floor" facebook group.

We used to have a neat little database query engine called pH at Northwestern, which you could use to find the contact information for any University-affiliated person: professors, friends, that cute girl in class whose name you only know the first few letters of, et cetera. I say that in the past tense, because the coming of Facebook was The Terminator of the Web 2.0 universe. The service usurped pH within mere weeks, quickly becoming the de facto contact database for the greater Northwestern community. And man, those were the glory days.

What is Facebook now? It's Myspace without the seizure-inducing blinking backgrounds and crappy teenpop music. I've come to abhor the direction this once-great enterprise is headed. And it's not just the official Facebook developers who are to blame; it's y-o-u.

The success of Facebook has always be largely due to its clean, uniform design. Prior to the service's descent into utter lunacy, every person's profile page was identical. You could change the information, you could even toss in a hyperlink or two. But you couldn't adjust the page's contcnts around, nor could you add any useless (blinking) crap. And while I usually foam at the mouth when I can't tweak something to my preferred specifications and colors, I quickly began to appreciate the simplicity of Facebook's look.

And then Facebook introduced its developer platform.

In short, this allows anyone to create custom applications that introduce themselves into the Facebook architecture. Some are inherently helpful, like "My Flickr," which allows me to stick a display of the last x number of photos I upload to my Flickr account. There's also the Twitter application, accomplishing the same purpose as the Flickr application, but with text. Yes, you can even add daily images of adorable cats to your profile.

With the good comes the bad, however. Not a day goes by that I don't get bugged by some errant application that one of my 595 friends has decided to install. I've been offered the option to transform into a zombie; I've been bitten by a Facebook vampire; I've been asked to hang out at a virtual happy hour; I've been poked, hugged, and touched in all sorts of strange and interesting ways; I've become someone's top friend; I've been recruited to cyber-save Darfur; and I've been hit with a Harry Potter spell. Enough!

Yes, I'm sure there's a way I can turn off all these notifications via some fancy privacy setting in Facebook. But there's no way I can hand-of-god smite these off everyone else's profile. I just want information -- I want contact details, I want bands of interest, and I want witty wall commentary. I don't want to sift through 83 different, colorful, image-heavy applications full of useless junk just to do so.

Facebook has jumped the shark by allowing its users to have unfettered access to profile modification, and it's only a matter of time before the next great Web 2.0/3.0/whatever application comes along and starts chipping users away. Don't believe me? It's already happening. Myspace used to be the end-all-be-all of social networking sites, but its golden age has long since passed. According to comScore Media Metrix, Myspace is seeing 30% fewer visitors under the age of 18, whereas Facebook is nearly tripling. Prior to 2004, who would have ever thought that Myspace would be anything but the Web's best social network? And yet, here we are.

Mark my words, Facebook. The more you expand your service into these uncharted waters, the closer you'll sail near all the other decaying social networks of our time. Innovation is awesome, but not at the expense of the quality of the experience.  Stop letting your users destroy your best features, and for the love of all that is holy, at least get them to stop inviting me into the application overload.



+ Add a Comment


I have begun removing friends because of this fact. STOP FREEKING INVITING ME TO STUPID APPLICATIONS! It's always the immature high school kids too.



I for one preferred the elitist Facebook. Just the best colleges, and no blinky things. With the apps and the everyone-can-join mentality, there's not much setting it apart from MySpace, which means there's less reason to be on both networks.

I currently AM on both, obviously, but Facebook is making me sad. I thought better of my friends before they had the power to ruin their facebook profiles like they've already ruined their MySpaces.

That being said, I have to stay on Facebook, if only to administer the Murphtastic! group.



Yeah, because when everyone can join your elitist network, who's left for you to be cooler than?

But seriously, Facebook is circling the myspace-visual-atrocity drain with all these apps. I don't want to be a vampire or a zombie, thanks.



"Yeah, because when everyone can join your elitist network, who's left for you to be cooler than?"

You, space monkey.

My point was that now that MySpace and Facebook are open to the same user base, and Facebook seems to be exercising no quality or aesthetic control over its developer platform, there's less reason to choose Facebook over myspace.

Plus, yeah, I am elitist. But it's not a matter of BEING cooler, it's a matter of APPEARING cooler. If anyone can join Facebook, how will everyone know how awesome I am, just because I'm on Facebook?



Don't you guys have Facebook pages for this kind of inane chatter?



WillSmith: "Don't you guys have Facebook pages for this kind of inane chatter?"

We do, but haven't you heard? Facebook is so over.

Nathan: I am a *code* monkey, you half-monkey half-pony monster.



*starts flexing his mighty moderator fingers*


Darth Ninja

if you dont like myspace / facebook, check out Micro$oft's

But if you dont want a URL like then you might be out of luck

Good luck,



UGH!! You are totally right. I enjoy Facebook because of its simple interface, and easy way to contact people and get information. The reason I quit myspace was because it took forever to load, the images were annoying, and the colors hurt my eyes.

Please facebook, don't!

I find it annoying that we have to switch Web 2.0 networks so often. I want a stable social networking site that I can easily track and keep in touch with people that I meet.


D Waterhouse

Facebook was wrong to let in high school kids, and it is now dead because of the developer applets.

That essay you linked to didn't seem to be a very empirical study, at least not upon cursory examination. Personal experience seems to validate her points though.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.