Reviews

Windows Home Server

comment Commentsprint Printemail EmailDeliciousDiggStumbleUponReddit

We’ve long encouraged our readers to embrace the power of a dedicated home server—we love the flexibility an always-on rig provides to host media, important documents, and other vital data. But, it’s not a simple proposition—XP isn’t particularly well suited to server duties, and setting up and maintaining Linux can be a challenge. That’s where Windows Home Server steps in.

Microsoft started with the solid base of Windows Server 2003, then stripped out everything but the necessities. From that bare-bones base, the Home Server team added crucial functionality for home users: Universal Plug and Play (UPnP) media sharing, an automated backup solution, rig health monitoring, and an innovative disk management scheme. The result is a rock-solid piece of software that is outstanding today and hints at even more amazing functionality to come.

Naturally, Home Server includes basic file-sharing functionality, shipping with default shares for music, photos, and video. You can configure per-user permissions for each share and create custom shares for specific purposes. Additionally, you can stream content to an Xbox 360 or other UPnP-compatible client directly from the shares.

Home Server’s sexiest feature is Server Storage, which essentially accumulates all the available space on all the hard drives in your system into one massive volume. If you have more than one drive in your system, you can even configure individual shares so that data is automatically stored on more than one hard drive. Configuring a new drive or removing an older drive is a simple procedure.

Once you’ve installed the included Home Server Connector software on your PCs, it will notify you of any potential problems, like out of date antivirus software or machines that have missed updates. Best of all, Home Server includes everything you need to do automatic backups of up to 10 machines connected to your home network. Restoring those backups is as simple as booting off of the included CD and selecting the backup you want to restore.

While Home Server won’t be available from retailers, power users will be able to purchase an OEM bundle from sites like Newegg.com. It’s a great piece of software, and it absolutely blows lesser-featured NAS boxes out of the water.

Click to Enlarge

Home Server features a GUI that dumbs down the basic Windows Server interface without omitting any functionality we need.

Microsoft Windows Home Server
www.microsoft.com
plus
Homing Missile

Rock-solid performance and loads of backup and other network features make this one Windows OS we can enthusiastically support.

minus
Home Invasion

Not available at retail.

COMMENTS
avatarFree 120-day WHS eval DVD's from Microsoft

Microsoft is currently giving away free Windows Home Server 120 day evaluation DVD's,

up to 3 copies, free shipping at:

 

http://www.microsoft.com/products/info/product.aspx?view=22&pcid=4f5e9c85-7167-4749-9af7-0d28d9483699&crumb=catpage&catid=9d273393-92c9-4807-be9c-515a0d152415

Login or register to post comments
avatarThis is not a review

It's an endorsement. In fact it's more like an MS press release for the product. Bill Gates himself couldn't have written it better, it's so glowing.
Can we expect a 'real review' on this product any time soon?
We need to know the negatives as well as the positives if we are to make an informed choice.
Rock-solid software??? There is no such thing!!!
It would be interesting to see side by side comparisons against NAS boxes too, to see how exactly WHS 'blows them out of the water'.

Login or register to post comments
avatarCall it an endorsement if

Call it an endorsement if you want, they've done a really nice job with the software, for once. Aside from the data corruption issue, which I didn't experience and affects a relatively small number of applications, I don't know anyone who's unhappy with what they've done.

There are benchmarks in the next issue, when I review the HP Home Server box, and tested it against my homebrew server (an Athlon X2 4800, 2GB memory, and a boatload of hard drives) and the fastest NAS box we've ever tested. My homebrew server ended up faster than either of the other two devices, and the HP was slightly slower than the NAS box.

For the automated backups and other niceties though, I'll happily sacrifice a little speed.

Login or register to post comments
avatarStreaming media uses

I was wondering if there is an easy way to turn an old XP box into a media center type thing through WHS, or if this is only available on XP MCE/Vista or XBox 360.

Also, is there an easy way to get roaming profiles on a home network with this? It certainly would be a nice thing, although I guess these days everyone has multiple laptops in the household.

Login or register to post comments
avatarRoaming Profiles

WHS would have to support a Domain which I bet is stripped out. Roaming profiles only work in a server domain, not in a straight file server environment. Any one know if WHS supports a domain environment?
On a second note, roaming profiles also only work with XP Professional, not XP Home. Be prepared to pony up for XP upgrades.

Michael
NH

Login or register to post comments
avatarIssues with WHS...

There are loads of performance issues with WHS, including taking several minutes to pull up the console interface from a connected workstation and general poor performance on the server itself. All of this is made much worse when folder duplication is enabled. Buyer beware...

Login or register to post comments
avatarData loss

Microsoft just admitted that WHS is responsible for corruption of data with quite a few programs including a number of their own. Doesn't completely negate your review because WHS is still an excellent solution. Just bad timing.

Login or register to post comments
RESOURCE CENTER

THIS MONTH's ISSUE
FEATURE Windows Tips: Find out what works and what doesn't as we test the most commonly prescribed Windows tipsHOW TO Customize and streamline your Windows desktop Core i7 Check out Intel's next-gen chip, up close and personal The Reactor We preview the first production-ready oil-immersed PC

Don't have an account? Register Now! Forgot password?