Quantcast

Don't have an account? Register Now! Forgot password?

Related Articles
Maximum IT
Reviews

Western Digital Velociraptor

comment Commentsprint Printemail EmailDeliciousDiggStumbleUponRedditFacebookSlashdot

We've taken a look at engineering samples of Western Digital’s speedy new Velociraptor drive. Now that we have our hands on a final version of the drive, we’re ready to deliver a full review of the big beast itself. And not surprisingly, it’s every bit as fast as we anticipated.

This 300GB drive is made up of two 150GB platters that spin around at 10,000 RPM—the signature speed of the Raptor line. Western Digital is able to hit unprecedented speeds for a consumer-level drive this time around by shrinking the Velociraptor’s size to a 2.5-inch design. This reduces the size of the platters in turn, resulting in increased read and write speeds compared to a typical 3.5-inch storage device.

We saw excellent performance when running the Velociraptor through our synthetic and real-world storage benchmarks. The former had the Velociraptor pushing average read and write speeds of 108.4 MB/s and 100 MB/s, respectively. And the latter, represented by our PCMark05 benchmark, netted the Velociraptor a score 18 percent faster than our former speed demon, Samsung’s three-platter HD103UJ terabyte drive. Hands down, the Velociraptor is the quickest drive we’ve ever tested.

But it’s not perfect.

Western Digital has told us that the Velociraptor—at least, this version—is not a notebook drive. It’s designed strictly for desktop and enterprise environments, hence the large, black heatsink that supports the 2.5-inch drive. This is the Velociraptor’s thermal-padded "IcePak." It's a name given rather unnecessarily, as the drive portion of the Veloricaptor package actually feels cooler to the touch than most hard drives we’ve tested.

The IcePak doubles as a mounting mechanism to make the Velociraptor fit snugly within a case’s standard 3.5-inch drive bay. What doesn’t work with this drive, however, are hot-swapping mechanisms, like those found in a number of NAS boxes, external enclosures, and next-generation cases. And this isn’t a “wiggle it” version of not-working. The Velociraptor is incompatible with any configuration that requires you to slide the drive into fixed power and SATA connectors.

It’s a maddening issue that could have been easily fixed by, say, moving the 2.5-inch drive over a wee bit in the proper direction in the IcePak carriage. And although shifting the drive's positioning would invalidate the IcePak's supposed effectiveness, it's a trade-off we’re perfectly happy to make in order to be able to use the Velociraptor with a number of devices that it, being a hard drive, should fit. What good are killer speeds if you can’t even use them?

Click to Enlarge

Don't even think about removing the Velociraptor from its Icepak. Not unless you want to void your warranty, that is.

Western Digital Velociraptor
www.wdc.com
plus
QWANTZ

This is the fastest consumer-grade hard drive you can buy. Period.

minus
LAND BEFORE TIME

Doesn't fit into standard hot-swap bays of any variety. Can't rip the drive off its Icepak and use it in a notebook.

verdict:8
BENCHMARKS
  WD Velociraptor WD Raptor Samsung HD103UJ
HDTach Burst (MB/s) 249.7 117.6 204.5
HDTach Random Access (ms) 7.1 8.1 13.7
HDTach Average Read (MB/s) 108.4 65 96.8
HDTach Average Write (MB/s) 100 63 84.4
PCMark05 Overall 9450 5956 8014
All HDTach scores use HDTach 3.0.1.0. Best scores are bolded.
COMMENTS
avatarDoes it Fit ?

does this fit in cooler master 840 ?

Login or register to post comments
avatarre: Doesn't fit into standard hot-swap bays of any variety.

That is a serious design flaw for my purposes.  I have about 100 Raptors mounted in hot swap bays and Supermicro servers.  I was shopping for a dozen more this week.  Now I find out that WD has dropped the Raptor and eliminated our choice to use the Velociraptor.  That means no sale for WD.  I cannot believe their engineering stupidity.

It looks like we are stuck with 7200rpm sata drives now.

Login or register to post comments
avatarBought one at bestbuy last week

This raptor is every bit faster than its predecessors, you can barely hear the chatter with the hard drive out in the open. It's really silent! I'll be picking up another drive on friday and put them in RAID0.

Login or register to post comments
avatarlucky

lucky

Login or register to post comments
avatarwow

I know what I want for Chistmas!

Login or register to post comments
avatarNitpicking

It seems that you have to put something down in the negative column. While I and others have no problem with these negatives, somebody may want to put some VRaptors in a NAS Box... which may be less expensive than a NAS Box with Enterprise class 10k RPM drives (I don't price such things). Any such person will be disappointed if they try that.

If the "next gen" HD cage has non-movable connections for power and SATA became standard, we'd probably see a new version of the VRaptor that would fit. This drive is designed to be the fastest Desktop drive for consumers, based on WD's Enterprise class HDs. If it doesn't fit where it's not designed to go (a laptop for example) too bad (I'm sure somebody will try to mod a laptop/VRaptor to fit). For now my VRaptor sits in my tool less HD cage perfectly.

Login or register to post comments
avatar(veloci)Raptor envy?

Uh...never could quite figure out MaxPC's hardon for the raptor...fell out of favor on the best of the best list because nobody else made one, according to youse...and now, they make one faster and bigger and the problem seems to be you have trouble with its intended use
(no notebooks, no hotswap drives...boohoo)

HEY!

It's the fastest...it's the best.
Drop the yeabuts and fall to your knees.

If your only tool is a hammer,
every problem looks like a nail...

Login or register to post comments
avatarGrandpa

Hey, I love my Raptors! Nuf said. Faster is always better and the Raptors are better.

Login or register to post comments
This Month's Issue
FEATURE Windows XP/Vista/7 Tips!FEATURE Monitor Roundup: 7 LCDs ReviewedHOW TOMaster PhotoshopFEATUREAMD's Awesome New GPUWHITE PAPEROrganic LEDs