Quantcast

Don't have an account? Register Now! Forgot password?

Maximum IT
Watchdog

Registry Cleaning

comment Commentsprint Printemail EmailDeliciousDiggStumbleUponRedditFacebookSlashdot

The WatchdogThe Dog asked readers for their feedback regarding registry cleaners, and more specifically, RegCure, which the Dog took a hard look at in the July issue. The upshot? The handful of readers who use RegCure reported no serious issues with the application, but only one person felt that it actually improved system performance. While others thought that registry cleaners in general have nominal value as performance enhancers, some saw other reasons to use them.

Reader Eric Pullen says, “From a software/device-driver testing perspective, CCleaner has done a pretty good job of removing remnants of keys left behind by subpar software and device driver uninstallers. So CCleaner can act as a testing shortcut in certain cases, if you don’t have the time or feel the need to reload an entire clean OS image. CCleaner’s registry tool also works as a quick spyware checker. I had a case in which Windows Defender kept finding a malware program every so many days after deleting it, and I was able to track down the specific DLL file that was the culprit because CCleaner showed the orphan registry entry that remained after Windows Defender said it “removed” the threat. It was this registry entry that kept re-installing the malware from the suspect DLL file after a PC reboot.”

 

  EMAIL THE WATCHDOG If you feel you’ve gotten a raw deal and need assistance setting a vendor straight, email the Dog at watchdog@maximumpc.com. Please include a detailed explanation of your problem as well as any correspondence you have sent concerning the issue.

 

 

COMMENTS:7
COMMENTS
avatarRegistry Cleaners

Yeah I bought Regcure this morning and its like pulling teeth to get those clowns to send me a key code to register the product and use it. I am dealing with Pay Pal to try and get my money back they just won't respond to my e-mails, the aknowledge that they receive them but they won't send my code. Save your money and don't buy there product.

 

Login or register to post comments
avatarI agree with Airheadq

There are all kinds of registry cleaners out there, and CCleaner is among the safest. I've used a few other registry cleaners, and I'll share my subjective opinion of their relative safety and depth of cleaning using CCleaner as a baseline of 100%.

Registry cleaner in Advanced System Optimizer 2 - Safety: 100%; Depth: 105%

RegOrganizer 4 - Safety: 70%; Depth:  200%

UniBlue RegistryBooster 2 - Safety: 90%; Depth: 150%

RegSeeker 1.55 - Safety: 40%; Depth: 400+%

I should also mention that RegOrganizer and Advanced System Optimizer offer an option to defrag/compact the registry, and RegistryBooster 2 has the capability of rebuilding registry keys that they believe should be in place, in case an aggressive cleaning wiped them out.

Here're a couple of lists of registry cleaners:

http://registry-repair-software-review.toptenreviews.com/

http://lists.thedatalist.com/pages/Registry_Cleaners.php

Login or register to post comments
avatarRegistry Cleaning Explained

--And when he gets to heaven, --
--To St. Peter he will tell, --
--"Another Marine reporting, Sir,--
--I've served my time in Hell!" --

 

People like CCleaner because its very user friendly and doesn't screw up your system. But the thing is, CCleaner only cleans "safe" registry settings. These settings won't do much harm to your system and are "safe" to delete. However, there are two other kinds of registy settings which are "not safe" and finally "unknown". There are plenty of registry cleaner out there that find these keys. "Not Safe" are settings that may are may not screw up your system and "unknown" are settings that don't fit into either group but nonetheless invalid in the registry. The story is seems is which ones to delete. Obviously the safe ones and may or may not all the not safe and unknowns. People probably report that a registry cleaner screwed up their system but they probably deleted all the keys that showed up. Registry cleaning isn't an exact science if at all but its really up to the user in the end to decide what to do. CCleaner takes it out and only shows safe settings. I am unsure what the RegCure thing is, but people have to know what they're getting into before they attempt something of this magnitude. Its just another user error.

Login or register to post comments
avatarccleaner ftw

ccleaner is with a doubt an essential tool for any power user.  it is likely to cause "problems" for average users.  removing saved passwords is generally the only downside that i've come across with ccleaner.  (though it is optional). 

 as a power user, web designer, and a research student.  i find it necesary to use ccleaner to wipe temp data constantly since i do alot of file management.

Login or register to post comments
avatarRegsupreme Pro

Regsupreme Pro from Macecraft is pretty good. Been using for 5 years or so with no major problems.

http://www.macecraft.com

Login or register to post comments
avatarRegistry Cleaners

I used to use registry cleaners all the time but I've come to the conclusion that they are just more trouble than they are worth. I'm not even referring to the "shady" ones either, I'm talking about well known, reputable ones. I have yet to come across a cleaner that improved any type of real-life or synthetic benchmark to any degree that couldn't also be attributed to experimental/margin of error. Only once have I seen an error that couldn't be solved through the normal channels that had to be removed forcefully by means of registry cleaner, but that was the exception to the rule. Meow.

Login or register to post comments
avatarReg Cleaners...

I've used CCleaner now religiously for almost 4 months and i've never had a problem, i just like keeping my PC very tidy!! Keeps things running as they should...

Login or register to post comments

This Month's Issue
FEATURE How to Get FREE Programs, Services, Software & MoreFEATURE Digital Photo Printer RoundupHOW TOBuild a 3D CameraFEATUREDIY Arcade PCWHITE PAPERHow TRIM Works