The $500 PC Build-Off
Posted 10/26/07 at 06:25:41 PM | by The Maximum PC Staff
Hot on the heels of our annual Dream Machine—arguably the best hand-built rig that money can buy—two of our editors face a far more difficult undertaking: building a desktop system where money is an object and sacrifice is the name of the game.
Our intrepid staffers—Senior Editor Gordon Mah Ung and Associate Editor David Murphy—must navigate these unfamiliar waters with just $500 apiece. Let loose in a local electronics store, they’ll be given just 90 minutes to choose all the parts they need (other than tools) to build their respective budget boxes. We’re graciously allowing them to transfer a Windows XP license from a retired machine, so they can save some dough on the OS.
Assuming they survive the purchasing phase of the challenge, the editors will have a single afternoon in which to build their PCs, load the OS, and ensure their rigs’ stability. Then it’s on to the final phase: Each editor must benchmark and review his competitor’s finished product.
There are so many opportunities for mishaps and mayhem that we can barely stand the suspense. Let’s get started!
The 90-Minute Shopping Spree
Neither editor expected to use the full time allotted to them, but the vast selection of parts had both guys mentally mixing and matching possible configs, recalculating their price lists, and waiting on pokey sales clerks until the very last minutes.
Gordon's Purchases
| Gordon's Rig | ||||
| Part | Price | |||
| CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo E4300 | $130.00 | |||
| MOBO: ECS P965T-A | $59.42 | |||
| RAM: 1GB Crucial DDR2/667 | $39.99 | |||
| VIDEOCARD: EVGA e-GeForce 8500GT | $113.99 | |||
| HARD DRIVE: Maxtor 200GB 6L200MO SATA | $49.99 | |||
| OPTICAL DRIVE: Hewlett-Packard DVD840ri (refurb) | $24.99 | |||
| CASE: Raidmax ATX528B | $39.99 | |||
| MISC: Ghirardelli chocolate bar | $2.99 | |||
| SALES TAX (8.25%) | $37.82 | |||
| Total | $499.18 | |||
Graphics: With just three minutes left to grab a GPU and get to the checkout line, Gordon reached for a rock-bottom GeForce card, which actually offers DirectX 10 capability! His big worry is that DX10 support is nothing more than a checkbox feature, due to the budget card’s low clock speeds.
CPU: Intel’s budget Allendale CPU core features 2MB of L2 cache and an 800MHz front-side bus (down from the Conroe’s 1,066MHz FSB). But it still rocks the Celeron D’s world.
Power Supply: Gordon immediately thought, “Let’s hope we don’t have a burnout,” when he considered running this bargain-bin system on the free 380-watt power supply that Raidmax includes with its case. But, hey, at least Gordon thought to buy a case....
Dave's Purchases
| Dave's Rig | ||||
| Part | Price | |||
| CPU: Intel Core 2 Duo E4300 | $120.00 | |||
| CPU COOLER: Cooler Master X Dream P775 | $17.99 | |||
| MOBO: ECS P4M900T-M |
$65.99 |
|||
| RAM: Kingston DDR2 IGB (2 x 512MB) PC5300 | $54.99 | |||
| VIDEOCARD: EVGA GeForce 7600GS |
$99.99 |
|||
| HARD DRIVE: Maxtor 200GB 6L200MO SATA | $49.99 | |||
| OPTICAL DRIVE: HP DVD740 External 16x LightScribe (refurb) | $29.99 | |||
| PSU: 400w Ultra V Series | $39.99 | |||
| SALES TAX (8.25%) | $39.50 | |||
| Total | $518.43 | |||
| *Initially Dave was within the budget, but a major oversight had him doing a parts exchange that would cost him money . . . as well as his pride. | ||||
CPU: Dave chose the Core 2 Duo E4300 because of its reputation as an insane overclocker. He planned to take the proc to 3GHz and possibly beyond. That’s a far cry from its stock speed of 1.8GHz, and the reason he splurged on an aftermarket cooler. “I’m going to try and crank this baby,” says young Murphy.
Motherboard: Dual core, Core 2 Duo, what’s the diff? That’s what Dave thought when he picked up an ECS RC410L/800-M motherboard on his first trip to the store. That mobo supports an Intel dual-core chipset compatible with the Pentium D, not the Core 2 Duo he bought. “I’d like to blame the speed of purchasing and the English language for this screwup,” he says; “Dual core means two cores, regardless of the CPU generation.” His motherboard begged to differ.
Case: What, no case? In a frantic effort to save money and impress Maximum PC readers with his mad scissor skills, Dave chose to do without a standard computer case. Since the rules require the PCs to be both functional and moveable, his mad scheme is to fashion an enclosure out of the very cardboard boxes that contain his purchases. Utter brilliance? Pointless stupidity? A complete waste of packing tape? We’ll soon find out.
Next: Gordon's Budget Box!
I think the mistake both
Submitted by HeartBurnKid on Tue, 2007-10-30 10:53
I think the mistake both editors made here was going with Intel silicon. Athlon 64 X2s would probably be more cost-effective at this price point. A quick glance at Pricewatch shows the C2D E4300 going at $138.49, which is more than an Athlon 64 X2 5200 (going at $128.97), and motherboard prices are comparable. Sure, the C2D is a better chip family, but I think that, considering both sides were forced to go with the slowest C2D, the Athlon chip would probably outdo it nicely.
Oh, and I do agree with EBM as far as this serving a portion of your audience that normally goes unserved. I wouldn't mind seeing a few articles like this in the future -- I don't want to see MaxPC lose its gonzo, balls-to-the-wall attitude, but how about an occasional article putting, say, graphics card under $150 head to head? Call it the "Best of the Rest" or something.
Registered Linux User
Submitted by EarthBoundMisfit on Mon, 2007-10-29 15:51
Registered Linux User #404122
Microsoft has encountered a critical system error and must now shut down. Better get Bill Gate$ on the phone for this one.......
[img]http//i35.photobucket.com/albums/d183/NunofyaBidness/404122.png[/img]A few months ago...I voiced my displeasure that MaximumPC wasn't doing enough for some of its readers, in that not everyone could afford to drop the kind of money to build a DECENT gaming computer.
You folks have taken that to heart...and given people options as far as attempting to build cheaper rigs...and in that I give you many kudos.
Tell me gentlemen...how about ordering some parts from eBay next time??Glenn Condrey
I loved Gordon's review of
Submitted by LaurenB on Sat, 2007-10-27 09:31
I loved Gordon's review of Dave's rig. so funny
Teehee, $700 is the sweet spot methinks
Submitted by Link2Ib on Sat, 2007-10-27 13:21
I think $700 is the sweet spot for a cheap PC. You can get a good Athlon 64 x2 brisbane 2 with 2 gigs of ram and a decent graphics card with that much I think. In fact, what were you guys doing? My system sans Radeon HD 2900 Pro costs $600, and that's including Vista but before tax/shipping.
I had:
Athlon 64 x2 5000+ Brisbane core
2GB Mushkin DDR2
Gigabyte 690G mobo with some usable integrated graphics (i.e. runs vista without breaking a sweat)
seagate 200GB 7200.10 or something
Antec Sonata III with a 500W PSU included
lite-on 20x DVD-RW.
I guess if you cheat and leave out the OS that's $500, and then $100 more for a decent midrange graphics card and you've got a good low-end system or a very nice HTPC setup I think. Probably a Radeon HD 2600 or Geforce 8600 would be best in that case since I think you can get either of those for around $100 and they have some sort of video decoding chip that the high end GPUs don't have for some reason.Edit: I take that back, I think those cards are closer to $200 than $100. Still, $700 is a much more reasonable price than $500.
3 NEW COMMENT(S) | 3 TOTAL COMMENTS
2 NEW COMMENT(S) | 2 TOTAL COMMENTS









