Senators Call for Probe of Private Censorship

Senators Call for Probe of Private Censorship

Two senators have called for a congressional investigation into allegations that phone and internet service providers are suppressing certain speech based on its content. Democrat Byron Dorgan of North Dakota and Republican Olympia Snowe of Maine sent a joint request to the Commerce, Science, and Transportation Committee asking it to hold a hearing after several recent reports of content-based discrimination. Comcast recently admitted to “delaying” certain traffic on its network after it was caught terminating users' P2P connections. Last month, Verizon Wireless refused to allow the pro-choice group NARAL to use its network for a text messaging program, saying it had the right to block “controversial or unsavory” material. After a loud public response, Verizon made a quick about-face. And after similar public attention, AT&T deleted a term in its contract that had allowed the company to terminate customers' accounts for criticizing the company.

In light of such threats to communications, these two lawmakers want to look into whether the companies' actions represent an anticompetitive use of market power, which would be an antitrust violation. The First Amendment right to free speech only applies to governmental interference with speech; you don't have that vaunted right with respect to private companies. Phone companies as common carriers must service all comers, but that rule hasn't been applied to text messaging or cable internet service.  Antitrust would be an interesting angle to attack what is fundamentally a free speech issue: the telecom industry has extremely high barriers to entry, and many providers have regional monopolies, so one of the ways they can exert that power is by choosing what content is allowed to pass through their network.


Thumbnail photo courtesy of bimurch.



+ Add a Comment

Talcum X

The battleground: The Internet. It's Us vs Them as it's always been. I think all Comcast users should hop on to their P2P of choice and download the hell out of anything and everything, then get disconnected for "abuse" (or just flat out cancel service). Then when the customer base all gets booted, well, now they have no income. They told all their customers that they down want their money. I know, that would leave a lot of people without due to lack of competition in some areas. But, I would forgo the net for a few months to get my point across. Just my opinion. It my not be the best or even acceptable to some...but... :-/

Every morning is the dawn of a new error.



ComCast, Verizon, et al are gonna get their collective asses kicked. And then the government is gonna screw it up. As usual.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.