Quantcast

Don't have an account? Register Now! Forgot password?

Reviews

Western Digital My Book 3.0 1TB

comment Commentsprint Printemail EmailDeliciousDiggStumbleUponRedditFacebookSlashdot

We wouldn’t normally test two products from the same lineup in two consecutive issues of the magazine. But when Western Digital’s My Book 3.0 showed up just days after the March issue went to print (it's on newsstands now!), we knew we had to review it. It doesn’t have an e-label or capacity meter, like the My Book Elite. Nor does it include WD’s SmartWare backup software or hardware encryption. But the My Book 3.0 has one feature that makes it awesome: USB 3.0.

Oh, sweet mercy, yes.

The My Book 3.0 is, like its predecessors, a simple black shell, vaguely book-shaped, surrounding a 3.5-inch Caviar Green drive. It comes in four variations: 1TB or 2TB, and with or without a PCI-E 2.0 adapter card. The x1 PCI-E 2.0 card gives you two USB 3.0 SuperSpeed ports and is based on NEC’s PD720200 chipset. It’s worth noting that using an x1 PCI-E 2.0 slot limits the theoretical throughput of the USB 3.0 ports. USB 3.0’s maximum theoretical throughput per port is 5Gb/s, or 640MB/s, while a x1 PCI-E 2.0’s throughput is 500MB/s. But honestly, you’re unlikely to see any hard drive or SSD saturate USB 3.0 at this point.

We tested the My Book 3.0 on the same rig we used to test last month’s My Book Elite—an Asus P7P55D-based system running a 2.66GHz Core i5-750. For reference, we also tested the same drive in a USB 2.0 slot. In our standard HDTach full-drive variable-zone benchmark, the My Book 3.0’s average read speed was 88MB/s, with average writes of 66MB/s. By contrast, both the My Book 3.0 and My Book Elite, when connected to a USB 2.0 port on the motherboard, averaged around 31MB/s reads and 26MB/s writes.

USB 3.0 is just beginning to show up in consumer devices, including a few high-end motherboards, but most of the peripherals that employ the technology so far are external hard drives, which benefit most from the bandwidth upgrade.

The Western Digital My Book 3.0 probably won’t be the fastest USB 3.0 hard drive we test this year, simply because it’s one of the first. It’s absolutely no-frills; it doesn’t even come with backup software. But it’s fast and capacious, is first out of the gate, and brings affordable USB 3.0 to the masses—which puts the bottleneck back at the drive access speed where it belongs. That counts for a lot.

(Note: Our full review of the My Book Elite will be posted onlined soon.)

Western Digital My Book 3.0 1TB
C-3PO

USB 3.0 speed removes 33MB/s transfer limit; includes PCI-E adapter card.

Tosh.0

Don’t lose that USB SuperSpeed cable! No encryption or backup software.

score:9ka
Benchmarks

My Book 3.0 (USB 3.0
My Book 3.0 (USB 2.0
My Book Elite (USB 2.0)
Capacity
1TB
1TB
2TB
HDTach Avg. Read (MB/s)
88.0
31.6
30.2
HDTach Avg. Write (MB/s)
66.3
26.2
26.1
HDTach Burst (MB/s)
92.1
32.9
32.8
HDTach CPU Utilization
11%6%
12%
HDTach Random Access (ms)
16.6
16.4
21.4

Best scores are bolded. HDTach version 3.0.1.0 used.

COMMENTS
avatarCome on!

3CPO is better than Tosh.0?? you cant be serious!?

Login or register to post comments
avatarReliability and Software

I have had two My Book Homes fail. One with a bad HD, the other from a controller issue. I recently bought a new Passport drive for the wife's laptop but the Smartware program will not run after I reboot the system. Their tech support is good but I will probably return the Passport drive and get a Seagate.

Login or register to post comments
avatarReliability is an issue for me

Just this week my 2nd W-D external hard drive failed after less than 60 days use.  It lasted longer than the first one which died just over 30 days from the purchase date.  It seems that they fail right after I get all my data backed up on them-never before.  I have used their internal hard drives for years but will probably pass on this one-the bad taste is still in my mouth! 

 

Login or register to post comments
avatarHow does this compare with SATA speed?

  Should I expect USB 3.0 connected hard drives to be on the par with internal SATA read and write speeds? I am too lazy to go look for benchmarks...

Login or register to post comments
avatarMore or less, yes. They

More or less, yes. They won't always be exactly as fast, of course, but the USB 3.0 theoretical bandwidth limit is higher than the 3Gbps of the current SATA spec. So it largely depends on the controller.

Login or register to post comments
This Month's Issue
FEATURE Build a Crazy-Fast $647 PCFEATURE Six Single-Band 802.11n Routers ReviewedHOW TOTweak BitTorrent and FirefoxFEATUREClose Look at ClarkdaleWHITE PAPERLCD Panel Technology