Quantcast

Don't have an account? Register Now! Forgot password?

Maximum IT
Reviews

Samsung SH-S223

comment Commentsprint Printemail EmailDeliciousDiggStumbleUponRedditFacebookSlashdot

We’ll admit we’ve been perfectly content with Samsung’s SH-S203 DVD burner for more than a year. Once we were writing 4.38GB of data to a disc in five minutes flat, we were feeling pretty satisfied with the state of DVD technology. Nevertheless, we’re not about to turn our nose up at a performance increase. And that’s what Samsung’s latest DVD burner, the SH-S223, offers.

As you might have guessed from the name, the SH-S223 represents a jump from 20x to 22x DVD+/-R burn speeds. In our tests, this effectively shaved 12 seconds off the time it took to fill a single-layer DVD+R disc. The SH-S223 took 4:46 (min:sec) compared with the SH-S203’s flat 5:00. In both cases, we used 16x media, the fastest-rated media that’s readily available. And in both cases, the drives’ “over-speed” feature enabled them to burn data at higher than rated speeds. In the course of its write, the SH-S223 steadily climbed from a starting speed of 8.38x to 20.7x.

Besides the boost in DVD+/-R speeds, however, the SH-S223 has identical speed ratings to its predecessor for all other types of media. In our DVD+R DL write test, the SH-S223’s 16x rating for that media amounted to a write time of 13:13 using 8x media, a mere three seconds slower than the SH-S203. Again, the SH-S223’s over-speed feature kicked in, with a good portion of the burn occurring at 10x speed.

The SH-S223 is rated at 8x for DVD+RW and 6x for DVD-RW. We tested the drive with DVD-RW media rated at 4x. This time, rather than burning beyond the disc’s speed rating, the SH-S223 stuck to it, maintaining a 4x speed throughout and writing 4.38GB to the rewriteable disc in 14:56. This isn’t all that surprising, as drives typically perform much more conservatively with rewriteable media, given its greater propensity for write errors.

Like the SH-S203 before it, the SH-S223 connects to a PC using a SATA interface and comes bundled with a host of Nero apps.

While we see no need to graduate from a 20x DVD burner—particularly the SH-S203—to the SH-S223, this is the drive to get if you’re currently using anything less than an 18x model.

Samsung SH-S223
Big Ben

All the goodness of the SH-S203, plus faster DVD+/- writes.

Big Brother

We’d have preferred speed improvements across the board.

score:9ka
Benchmarks

Samsung SH-S223
Samsung SH-S203
DVD+R Write Speed Average
14.94x
13.45x
DVD+R Read Speed Average
12.16x
12.13x
Access Times (random/full) 117/204ms 116/198ms
DVD+DL Write Speed Average 9.12x
9x

Best scores are bolded. All tests were conducted using Nero CD DVD Speed and Verbatim media. Our test bed is a Windows XP SP2 machine using a 2.66GHz Intel Core 2 Quad Q6700, 2GB of Corsair DDR2/800 RAM on an EVGA 680 SLI motherboard, one EVGA GeForce 8800 GTS card, a Western Digital 500GB Caviar hard drive, and a PC Power and Cooling Turbo Cool PSU.

COMMENTS
avatarThey are both SATA, for the

They are both SATA, for the extra dollar you get lightscribe support.

Login or register to post comments
avatarmy bad, your right. I said

my bad, your right. I said one was pata and the other sata.

Login or register to post comments
avatarEr?

Isn't 12.16 > 12.13???

Login or register to post comments
avatarWhich One?

NewEgg shows both the SH-S233F and SH-S233Q so which one are we talking about here? Is the S233Q worth the extra Dollar? What's the differents?

Login or register to post comments
avatarone is sata and the other

one is sata and the other pata.

Login or register to post comments
avatarYeah, a DVD in 5 Minutes? 

Yeah, a DVD in 5 Minutes?  Tell them to update the firmware to get to that point.  That would be some useful info don't ya think. 

 

 

Xcore don't mean X processors dang it!!!

Login or register to post comments
avatarI have used 3 different

I have used 3 different brands of DVD's and I think the fastest I have burned one (about 4.3 gigs) was about 5:20. Most of the time it's about 5:45ish. Although when you burn mis-matched material, I.E. jpegs, video, and mp3's together, it takes longer to burn. So I try to stick to one file type if I can help it.

Login or register to post comments
avatarI've had this drive for

I've had this drive for months. Bought it from Newegg in fact. Good drive and can't really complain.

Login or register to post comments
avatarsome math issues

this may sound picky, but isnt 5minutes minus 12 seconds 4 min 48 secs?

Login or register to post comments
avatarSHHHHH! It's a secret!

SHHHHH! It's a secret!

Login or register to post comments
This Month's Issue
FEATURE Windows XP/Vista/7 Tips!FEATURE Monitor Roundup: 7 LCDs ReviewedHOW TOMaster PhotoshopFEATUREAMD's Awesome New GPUWHITE PAPEROrganic LEDs