D-Link DGL-4500 Xtreme N Gaming Router
Posted 04/13/09 at 12:30:24 PM by Michael Brown

Looking for a dual-band router so you can run two independent Wi-Fi networks, using one frequency band for data and the second for streaming media? Scratch the DGL-4500 off your list, because D-Link’s definition of “dual-band” means operating on either the 2.4GHz band or the 5.0GHz band—not both at the same time.
When we think of a dual-band router, we envision something like the Linksys WRT600N we’ve been using as a reference point. That device has separate 802.11n Draft 2.0 radios that enable us to run two independent wireless networks. That’s not to say the DGL-4500 is a lousy router; in fact, it delivered far superior performance at long distances than the WRT600N. Where the Linksys box is nearly useless when our Wi-Fi client is outside our test home—delivering throughput of just 0.7Mb/s at one exterior location and 1.2Mb/s at the other—the D-Link delivered exceptional throughput of 18.0Mb/s and 6.44Mb/s, respectively.
The DGL-4500 is also much easier to configure for use with Windows Home Server. While we had to manually configure port forwarding on the WRT600N in order to enable access to our server remotely from the Internet, the configuration wizard in Microsoft’s consumer server OS was able to set everything up automatically on the DGL-4500. And gamers will appreciate D-Link’s proprietary GameFuel technology, which analyzes network traffic and assigns higher priority to packets it identifies as being associated with games.
If you buy a DGL-4500, be sure and update it with the latest firmware. D-Link has added its SharePort feature, which enables the router to add USB devices such as printers and storage to your network and share them. The DGL-4500 exhibited impressive range and its gaming-oriented quality-of-service settings are handy for gaming, but that’s not enough to dislodge the WRT600N as our favorite router.
4/13/2009 Editor's Note: A reader brought the SharePort feature to our attention after reading this review in the March edition of the magazine; we issued a correction in the April issue and have added that feature to the online review. The bottom-line verdict has not changed from the print review. --MB
Excellent range, useful gaming-oriented QoS settings, informative display.
Not a true dual-band router, display automatically shuts off.
| D-Link DGL-4500 | Linksys WRT600N | |
|---|---|---|
| Kitchen, 20 feet (Mb/s) | 99.9 | 105.0 |
| Patio, 38 feet (Mb/s) | 65.3 | 74.3 |
| Bedroom, 60 feet (Mb/s) | 50.4 | 42.2 |
| Media Room, 35 feet (Mb/s) | 20.3 | 29.8 |
| Outdoors 1, 90 feet (Mb/s) | 18.0 | 0.7 |
| Outdoors 2, 85 feet (Mb/s) | 6.4 | 1.2 |
Best scores are bolded. Our test bed consists of a Core i7-965 Extreme Edition CPU, 6GB of Corsair DDR3/1600, an EVGA GeForce 280 GTX videocard, a PC Power and Cooling TurboCool 1200 power supply, a WD Raptor 150GB drive, and Vista Home Premium 64-bit. HD Tach scores were achieved using an Intel X25-M SSD.
I'm EXTREMELY happy w/ this router!
Submitted by DRAGONWEEZEL on Thu, 06/25/2009 - 4:52pm
I'm a cheap bastard, as I'm still paying for mistakes I made when I was younger. My DGL-4300 died on me after about 3 years of good solid service. Just on a whim, not really able to afford one, I did a google search for Site:craigslist.org DGL-4500. I found one for $70 and they shipped it to me!
I flashed to the newest firmware, 1.21 & d/led the newest shareport. It's way cool, I have a flashdrive, a printer, and a portable HDD all on a cheap $10 usb hub. It works GREAT w/ all of it!
Oh, and I play TF2 tons, and my laptop gets the best reception I've ever had!
THERE ARE ONLY 11 TYPES OF PEOPLE IN THIS WORLD. Those that think binary jokes are funny, those that don't, and those that don't know binary
I am running the DIR-655. It
Submitted by physicusman on Wed, 04/15/2009 - 4:36am
I am running the DIR-655. It has ALMOST all of the settings I desire in a router. Before this I had a Linksys WRT54G v8 with DDWRT Micro on it. That was the best setup ever. I know the 655 is 2.4ghz only, but I have the ability with this router to do just about everything the one in this review does except run on 5ghz. I don't see that as a downside because I can stream HD content on my laptop to my tv with hdmi from the laptop and it runs great. This router also has just about all the options that my ddwrt firmware gave me EXCEPT wake on lan. I miss that so much! :( And it has the ability to run a guest network too, so I actually have 2 wifi networks on one router. It also give you the ability to let the guest network see the regular one, so it gives me the best of both worlds. I run my regular network with full wpa2-aes and the guest with wep for friends/family and an old nintendo ds i have. :) But anyways, check out the DIR-655. It won't disappoint.
what about open source firmware?
Submitted by kw13tl33tg33k on Tue, 04/14/2009 - 6:46am
i have 2 crusty old linksys wrt54gs routers running ddwrt.....i would love to make the jump to n routers but cant seem to find a general consensus on what n router dual band or otherwise will work for me.
I have one of the routers configured as a bridge which works swell for gaming but when ever i try and stream video like tversity or something it takes forever to buffer and stutters and freezes
dont want to run cable...(i rent) so the bridge thing worked nice..
Can anyone suggest some n routers that work well with this setup? the current n routers from linksys are getting horrible reviews...and since i have to buy 2 of them...I want to make the right decision....
Thanks
I like it
Submitted by Vano on Mon, 04/13/2009 - 7:38pm
I've been using DGL-4500 since it's came out. Before that I was using it's older brother DGL-4300. I was quiet satesfied with both. Though compare two, besides the hardware differences and speed differences, DGL-4300 had more features in setup, for instance, in 4300 you could filter access by MAC for Wifi or LAN+WiFi, in 4500 you can only filter both LAN+WiFi, which is rediculous, especially when there is a limit of 24 MAC addresses and novdays many using virtual PCs...
Both routers works well with P2P (aka lots of simultanious connections), though I have to reboot once in a while if use P2P for a few days straight.
Using WiFi for my media PC (about 20 feet through 2 walls), streaming 1080p videos with no problem. File transfer is about 7mbyte/sec, via gigabit LAN is up to 50mb/sec.
There is one thing one must be aware of. The latest firware update is irreversable. If you flashed from v1.0x to 1.1x that's it, no way back to 1.0x - this really pissed me off, because the 1.1x is less stable with P2P.
DGL-4500 supports Dynamic DNS sites. Even though in the available dropdown list there is only 3 sites (probably these who paid them), it actually supports more then that. You can use no-ip.com, changeip.com and many others :)
P.S.
With DGL-4500 I had a bad lock up a few times when all 4 LAN ports
where used entire network become unaccessable, the only solution was
reflash firmware, hopefully there is settings backup feature.
WRT600N
Submitted by Bustout on Mon, 04/13/2009 - 9:54am
So when are we going to get an updated best of the best router? Itcannot still be the WRT600N. It has received many bad user reviews, and its successors have gotten worse reviews. And the WRT600N is hard to find now with some people selling them for nearly $500.
seconded...
Submitted by BaggerX on Tue, 04/14/2009 - 6:23am
It's definitely time to revisit the router issue and choose a new king...
Feature
Review
Feature
Feature
Feature





