The Music Industry Abandons Lawsuits and gets Ready to Boot Offenders off the Net



+ Add a Comment


FTW.  If you can't DL stuff w/o getting caught. Don't do it.

As long as there is DRM there will be pirates. And pirates can grow / expand / crack stuff faster than the idiot software commies and RIAA can't block them.

Oh, and philly, tongue shovel my stink ditch. Hater.



This isn't going to stop anybody but the technically challenged, many of whom probably aren't even doing anything wrong.  Anybody who even knows anybody who uses BitTorrent and its associated download programs knows how to block "spy" IP addresses from the RIAA, MPAA, and other general snoopers.  If you meet someone with any technical skill who admits to downloading copyrighted works, you can't help but ask "aren't you afraid you'll get in trouble," to which the answer will probably be "no - I use PeerGuardian".  PeerGuardian is nice even if you just want to supplement your firewall with one of many blacklists of IP addresses for internet nasties.  I would even consider using a good blacklist like this to protect my server from known bad IPs -- something supported in several good firewalls.

If the RIAA really wants to reduce piracy, save money, and make money, they should work out a deal allowing songs to be sold for $0.25 per track, DRM free, in high quality and any format.  Save the CD artwork and touchy-feelies for the people that want them, and charge a few bucks more.  Russian music sites make a killing from US customers using a similar model, which is likely legal by some gray-area legalities and would be solidified by Russia's WTO membership.  The RIAA just needs to let US companies compete to get their hands in that money pot.  Until reality is a little closer to this, I'll just do without or wait for $5 album downloads, thanks.  At least we're reaching the DRM-free mark, now just to get the track prices to a more reasonable level.

Then again, maybe artists and studios will see the light and separate themselves from the RIAA.  We can dream.  End artist slavery!



i live in Australia and this isn’t goingto stop me i have received an e-mail from my isp (we believe you aredownloading illegal games blah blah blah) i sent them a message back explainingthat i would never do such a thing i wouldn’t even know how to (lol) so theysent me an e-mail back saying sorry. 

they are all such pushovers 



This isn't a new idea: the ISDA's been doing it for years. Many years ago, I got a letter from Time-Warner Cable that included a letter from the ISDA claiming I had upload a piece of pirated software. TWC killed my connection for 24 hours. *shrug*


How big exactly does a number have to be before it can be copyrighted?



I wonder how this complies with the ISPs eua?



I've already gotten one of those cease and desist letters, only it was for a movie. People using utorrent and on Charter Communications should watch out. I don't blame utorrent so much, but the fact that charter not only knew I had downloaded the movie but sent me the syntax printout for the download is a little worrisome.



I fail to see how this will be any different than what the RIAA did before.  Piracy can't be stomped out like this; the only weapon that is guaranteed to work is the market (witness the meteoric rise of iTunes).  Threats and bullying only make the RIAA look bad.  People feel like they are "sticking it to the man" so it actually encourages piracy.

Further, I foresee the same ham-handed, mistake-prone process being employed again, except the consequence is loss of internet rather than a fine.  This isn't going to work out well either.



1st Amendment

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or
prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of
speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to
assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

the internet is a major form of communication and is one of the best ways to express our ideas and feeelings and disconnectiong me, i believe, is what is called a "abridging the freedom of
speech" abriging, look it up in the dictionary

just an opinion



Why Don't they just put this much effort into getting child pornography sharers prosecuted.



smart people just buy the music anyway instead of stealing it.



ha ha ha that is a joke right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



Lets see this work on  a college campus.  You can't pinpoint anybody on a campus just by their IP.  Most are hooking wireless routers up in their dorm rooms so there could be several hundred people that could be at fault.  I didn't think it could get much more rediculous than them sueing people, but I think they just one-upped themselves.


PS: The smart people will always find a way around the RIAA.  All they will get are the stupid people.



Less stupid people on the Internet sounds fantastic to me...  I'm actually kinda torn on this issue now.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.