Seagate Reportedly Balked at Western Digital's Takeover Talks



+ Add a Comment


Thank God this didn't go through.  WD drives are total shit.  I have had 8 go bad in the past three years alone.  I guess if they do end up with Seagate I will switch to Hitachi.



The healthy competition is only going to be there if the companies remain separate.  I imagine these two will be the last ones standing in the rotational media fight to the death before SSDs rule the earth.

In other news, I have the exact opposite experience of the other poster with respect to drive failures.  It is funny how those statistics classes come back to mind and I see all these standard distributions in my head.



I've had the exact opposite of big_montana as well - five Seagates failed in the past year, all of them less than three years old, but I have WDs that are five years old plus that are still humming along.  Hell, one of them is a six year old Caviar 80GB that still hasn't developed a bad sector or slowed down at all.

I definitely agree with the bit about Maxtor, though.  Almost as bad as the notorious Hitachi



Sometimes for kicks, I go on Newegg, and read hard drive reviews. Can't tell how many times someone's said "Excellent drive. I always buy from manufacturer X" followed by "This drive failed in a week, manu X sucks, I will always buy manu Y from now on." Then I go to on of manu Y's drives, and see it the other way around.



I'm glad this deal fell through, aside form teh alck of competition and increased prices aspect. I just do not think WD drives are as reliable as Seageates. All the drives that I have fialed over the last three years have been WD's (the newest being 6 months old). I have 4 year old Seagates that still run fine, and none of my newer WD's are still alive. WD is the new Maxtor.



And I've had three Seagate drives die in a short period of time, and yet all of my WD drives (about ten of them) all are running well, the oldest being 6 years old.  So I guess YMMV.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.