Researchers Think They Know Why Wi-Fi Drains Your Cell Phone
Battery performance on Wi-Fi enabled devices varies pretty wildly based on our experience, but the folks over at technologyreview.com think they finally know why. According to researchers over at the University of Texas, most Wi-Fi enabled access points don't properly implement the protocol designed to reduce the power drain on mobile devices. This makes performance somewhat inconsistent, but researchers think it's something that can be addressed going forward.
The power saving mode was designed to allow mobile devices to enter a "sleep" mode between packet requests, however most end up staying in a fully powered up state until the completion of the entire transfer. Depending on the size of the file, and the network latency, this can add a considerable amount of additional battery drain. Head researcher Eric Rozner concluded that "an HTC Tilt's total power consumption increases by threefold when using Wi-Fi". 3G data caps are likely to increase consumer dependence on Wi-Fi in the future, so clearly this is a problem that deserves a bit of attention.
We hope this is something the handset makers find a way to address given the relative ease of pushing updates to smartphone platforms, but if the problem is indeed with the access points, I wouldn't count on this unfortunate situation resolving itself anytime soon. Isn't this why we have the Wi-Fi Alliance? I guess they are still licking their wounds after arguing about 802.11n for seven years.
Comments
Comments are closed on this article
![]()
Enchilada
June 28, 2010 at 2:54pm
Having worked at a company that tried to implement this on a wireless networking device, the real problem is that most routers have not implemented the standard correctly.
It's a big problem that in most cases when your wireless device device goes to "sleep" it never wakes up again because the router isn't compatible and won't send a proper "wake up" packet.
So the device makers give up and set the devices to never go to sleep... no more issues.
I remember Nokia has an extensive whitepaper on the issue. I don't know if we ever solved it.
![]()
BigC
June 27, 2010 at 6:17pm
At first, i read the title, and the first thing I did was give myself a facepalm.
Come to find out after reading this article it makes sense. I have seen this kind of effect happen to my first gen ipod Touch. Safari will still be rendering pages after I put the device into sleep mode.
![]()
TechJunkie
June 27, 2010 at 1:36pm
To hell with these so called researchers. Just move to sprint and problem solved. No data caps on 3G and/or 4G with the EVO. I get 2.68 down and .854 up consistantly so there is no need for wifi. I'm in central florida and I use a server in Kansas to measure my speed using the speedtest app for EVO/Droid. EVO FTW!
I have to PooP!
![]()
Caboose
June 27, 2010 at 8:19pm
Right, because you know, Sprint is available in all areas of the world.
Ya, I'm gonna go sign up for Sprint, and pay roaming charges, etc up in Canada.
What about if you're in an area of the USA where there is limited Sprint coverage, or there's no 3G or 4G, but you've got ample WiFi available?
Or on an airplane. If they don't allow cell phone usage, but WiFi is fine?
-= I don't want to be dead, I want to be alive! Or... a cowboy! =-
![]()
TechJunkie
June 28, 2010 at 5:33am
Well your right. But I was basically targeting people in the US market, hence the AT&T users....saying AT&T sucks. That's all. Sorry if I offended you.
Using wifi, such as at a starbucks, or a wifi enabled mcdonalds in a limited 3G or 4G area for short periods (not marathon internet usage) is fine. Sure, your batt usage is going to drain, but you need to know the limits of your phone. If you have a PC at home with internet, wifi, etc, use your PC. But people are so incessant on using thier cell phone wifi instead of thier PC because of convenience, thus killing their battery prematurely then they complain about it. Some people treat smartphones like an 8 hour toting netbook with an 8 cell battery. You just can't do that. Smartphones are meant to be quick convenience, not a replacement.
But these so called researchers aren't saying anything new that we didn't already know. They just want notoriety to justify grants that they get from their gov't and private institutions.
I have to PooP!
Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook
Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

















