Original Xbox Users Upgrade to 360 or Lose LIVE Gaming



+ Add a Comment


 No problem for me. But then, it sure would be nice if MS is going to fark their loyal Xbox Original folks over like this, MS should be offering them a $100-$150 coupon to upgrade. MS would make that money back in no time as the oreiginal Xbox users get into the Xbox360 scene and start gobbling up Live products left and right in their new found Xbox360 goodness. 

*****MaximumPC Moderator. Report inappropriate/SPAM comments to
QuakindudeMod at Gmail--dot--com with a link. My personal comments do not necessarily
reflect the opinions of MaxPC or Future US*****



So those with the OXbox get a 360 for $50? I really cannot say I agree with that. The OXbox is just too far out of date in comparison to the 360... they should have dropped it a long time ago. They don't make games or accessories for it anymore, do they?



They've done the math and it's easy math to do, too. Start with, how many people still access LIVE with the original XBox? Of those people, how many do so exclusively? After all, if you already have a 360, you're not likely to drop LIVE because your XBox is no longer compatiable. So, how many people use the XBox Uno exclusively? And... of those... how many are likely to drop their accounts completely, forever, never again joining the LIVE community?

We're talking a subset of a subset. A minority of a minority. It's like asking how many left handed Americans are over 6' tall? 10% of Americans are thought to be left handed. Population is 300 million, so 30 million lefties. Less than 4% of Americans are over 6 feet tall, so 1.2 million are both left handed and over 6 feet tall. Applying this numbers to Microsoft's numbers, if <10% use only the Xbox to access LIVE and <4% of those will never rejoin; of their 23 million members, they lose 920,000, or, 4% of them. Anyone want to guess how many of them have an Xbox Gold account?

Look! A distraction!



Think about it Microsoft says the life span for the Xbox 360 is ten years. So what if after 7 or 8 years they discontinue service? I would not be a happy camper. And i refuse to pay for a gold account.


I Jedi

I find it amazing that people are still using the regular Xbox, and in enough numbers to make Microsoft want to drop them. Personally, I feel that a majority of people with a regular Xbox still may be too poor to afford to upgrade to the 360. I could be wrong, but why wouldn't people want to get the Xbox 360 over the Xbox, if they could? Maybe because they only ever play one specific multi-player game? If so, that game probably has long been loosing participants in its Xbox Live multi-player arenas, as it is probably an older game, like Halo 2 or Gears of War 1.

I also think that the time-frame given to the original Xbox owners is a bit too fast... Microsoft may have given a 2 and a half month notice, but I think they should have given a notice of at least 6 months, so that they could save up, rather than be rushed to get a new one in the short time frame they now have. Either way, I think it is a stupid decision to force them to switch, unless it was costing Microsoft money to keep them online; however, if the reason they are doing this is to get them to buy online content then I frown upon Microsoft's decision. They are just a company, I guess.



Well I find it amazing that they could be playing Gears of War "1" on an xbox since it was one of the first xbox 360 games to come out.  :)



 This isn't surprising at all. Eventually the user base becomes too small, and/or the cost of maintence is too high to continue support it so it gets shut down. Heck, if everything was supported forever, there'd still be Windows 3.1 updates being rolled out regularily, VHS movies would still be in production and the very first cell phones would still be in full use today.


-= I don't want to be dead, I want to be alive! Or... a cowboy! =-



microsoft dropping support for old xbox game, I cant say i didnt see it coming. I still have my old xbox still play a few games, wish I could play more xbox games on my 360. About 2/3rds of my games wont run on the 360. They havent updated the compatibility list in over 2 years, I was hoping at least one day I would be able to run most my games on the 360. Guess I will have to keep the old beast around a bit longer so I can still play the classic xbox games.



PC's definately take the gaming cake still. My PC blows away the 360 and PS3 , and I can play my older games too, and I don't need to upgrade or downgrade or any of that floppy horse ****. Anyway, it's still a shame to see them dump their regular xbox users like that.



As long as there's even one person out there still willing to run a server, I can play 10 year old games to my heart's content without depending on the publisher, MS, or anybody else.

Advantage: PC.



Except the games that rely on central servers (the bulk of EA's games, Modern Warfare 2), of course. 

Honorary Family Member:

Phenom II x4 925 2.8 GHz

XFX Radeon HD 5870

8GB G.Skill DDR2-800 RAM

ASUS M3A32-MVP Deluxe 

Seagate Barracuda 750GB HDD  



Mighty BOB!

Oh you mean those games I don't care about?  PC still has the advantage.



Cue the haters of Microsoft and the fear-mongers who oppose change--probably people who still use XP too.

Come on folks. The basic 360 clocks in at two-hundred bucks, and plays most (if not all) of your old Xbox games. It's a media center, connects to your PC, has several add-ons to improve functionality, and is overall just plain better.

And before people cite the RROD, that's practically a non-issue these days. And if you want Xbox Live, it's looking like you won't have much of a choice come April. I don't see this being a big problem though. The original Xbox, I don't hear much about, except when it comes to mods, so I doubt it's another case of WinXP.



I was really disappointed in the number of games not supported on the 360! About half of the games I owned were not compatible. Only the biggest sellers were ported. After how much the backwards compatibility was hyped, I felt a little ripped off, and in my case I no longer had the original xbox to play them on either.





This announcement pertains to original X-Box games period, whether played through an original X-Box or through the 360's emulation.  Buying a 360 doesn't solve the major problem -- i.e. you still can't play those games online anymore.



Now see, THAT IS a problem. For those who want to play Halo's 1 or 2 and such, then I doubt that crowd would be very happy with this news. But I don't know many people who do play the Xbox classics--online at least. If it becomes a common complaint, I anticipate a software or emulation update that would fix that problem. Don't anticipate much of an uproar though.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.