Microsoft on Patents: Can't We All Just Get Along?

32

Comments

Comments are closed on this article

avatar

HRO

Somehow, the first time I read "standard essential patents available to all, on fair, reasonable, and nondiscriminatory terms" I found "price" lurking. well... must be me.

Will Microsoft being "fair and reasonable" include stopping bleeding the Android market by collecting their licence royalties? I guess that is not what being "fair and reasonable" meant.

• HRO •

avatar

Penterax

Bleeding?

Microsoft's position was that Android used some of MS's technology. Apparently, Samsung agreed enough to pay MS licensing fees for that technology. Excuse them for wanting to make money on their own hard work!

Microsoft never filed to have Android phone sales stopped - Apple has.

avatar

Engelsstaub

I've criticized Microsoft here in the past; especially in relation to their claims of Linux "infringing" on their patents. I'm just going to admit that they're being somewhat decent otherwise. It's pretty hard for corporations like MS, Apple, and Google not to step on each other's toes a bit. I wish they would all just play to their own strengths and stop litigating (and, in some cases, blatantly infringing.) My interest, as a consumer, is that I use and like products from each of these companies.

avatar

cpuking2010

Awe did little micro$oft get scared of the patent portfolio that Google just bought? Guess what, Karma is a Bitch!

avatar

someuid

Ha. This is funny coming from Microsoft, especially when they make such a big fuss when some company signs a 'no sue for Linux' contract with Microsoft.

avatar

Supall

So what are Standard Essential patents?

avatar

TRYER

It's like some company putting a patent on Ketchup or trying to patent a word people use daily. Silly but they are both essential.

avatar

Bullwinkle J Moose

Well, I was hoping that MICROSOFT SECURITY ESSENTIALS ability to send data to and from ANY PERSONS Windows Computer "WHILE" All software was BLOCKED from doing this in the users Firewall would be covered under such a Patent Agreement

However,

Since Windows is a Spyware Platform used by the Gov't, it doesn't appear to be a function that Microsoft considers "Essential" or "Patentable" for others to use but rather "Essential" yet "Classified" for Internal and Gov't use Only!

Maybe Maximum Propaganda or the Non-Believers out there can verify what I just said by blocking ALL traffic in their firewall and then updating Security Essentials over the Internet

(I used a "Registered" copy of XP-SP3 with all the Microsoft Critical Spyware Updates for this test)

Once you have verified that Microsoft is sending data to and from your computer without authorization, ask yourself the following question>

NOW who's wearing the Tinfoil Hat?

avatar

Cregan89

Microsoft Security Essentials controls the Windows Firewall when installed, so colour me not surprised that MSE doesn't block itself from updating itself. Use a third party firewall and I guarantee you that it will block MSE updates.

And you've still yet to explain to me how ANY software, including MS Windows, could possibly get by a hardware firewall? I'm all ears...

avatar

Bullwinkle J Moose

I used Sygate Pro firewall which blocks both incoming and outgoing data from anything including Microsoft's core functions (features) except when certain items are changed

For example,

I noticed security software began breaking the firewall when AVG went from version 7.0 to version 8.0

In AVG 7.0 the firewall worked fine!
But, once you update to version 8, programs, keyloggers, trojans and virtually anything else you could think of began accessing the Internet directly even though EVERYTHING was blocked in the firewall

In AVG version 9, they fixed the antivirus to prevent the end user from seeing that programs were actually connecting to the Internet when blocked in the firewall but you can see that they were still disabling the firewall by reading the license in AVG 9

This was the beginning of logging what programs were running on a users machine without the user being aware of it

This stealth behavior was expanded upon with Microsoft service pack 3 and later updates

This same behavior is seen with security essentials yet the firewall gives you no warning because the program updates fine while everything is blocked from Internet access and no firewall warning popup occurs with security essentials when it begins updating

Others here will complain that Sygate was a security risk and should be updated to a more secure firewall, yet when you do that you will not see what is connecting to the Internet in the background

I believe the updated firewalls were merely to prevent the end user from seeing what was connecting to the Internet when EVERYTHING is blocked in your firewall

At least with Sygate, we can see what they are doing!

For those who go the packet sniffer route...
I don't care what your packet sniffer says!
If the Light on my wireless dongle is blinking, data is being sent!
With SP2 or AVG 7 and earlier, the light diddn't blink when everything was blocked in the firewall!

With SP3, AVG 8 and later or Security Essentials installed, the light blinks regardless of what I block in the firewall BECAUSE DATA IS BEING SENT!

Welcome to HELL!

avatar

Kromix

i has a tinfoil hat too O.o

avatar

LatiosXT

I'm pretty sure in the EULA it said they were going to send data off. And there's privacy policies.

So either you're trolling, you're just a stupid kid.

avatar

Bullwinkle J Moose

"pretty Sure" doesn't cut it around here kid!

YOU might not think it's suspicious to just send data off to the Internet, but to do so even though your Firewall has blocked ALL programs from sending or receiving data to/from the Internet is a prime indicator of a backdoor

To do so without the firewall even giving you a popup is a DEFINITE indicator to a back door

To call others stupid or a troll without understanding the consequences of the actions just described is usually an indicator that you are an insider trying to protect your illegal spyware operation

However, in aprox 2 out of 10 cases, the person making such a retarded statement as you have just made indicates that you are lacking intelligence and are the type of person who goes around the Internet making retarded statements like you just did without ever once checking whether I was offering proof of my claim by checking what I said for yourself on your own computer

I'll give you the benefit of the doub't in this case untill you check my findings for yourself

Please verify what I said in my original post and refrain from reposting untill you understand the consequences of what it means to have a back door "in" and out of any Windows computer without consent and without being notified by a firewall

However,
If you continue to make statements like you just did, I will no longer give you the benefit of the doubt!

Have a nice day :)

avatar

kevaskous

The later

avatar

Bullwinkle J Moose

Really?

R E A L L Y ?

Do these people REALLY think its a great idea to have Microsoft or the Gov't sending and receiving data from their computers without having the ability to block that transfer in the firewall

Or letting Microsoft and the Gov't send and receive data from their computers without being notified by their firewall that it's even happening?

Once again for the Noobs....

Download a fresh copy of MS security essentials, then block ALL programs from accessing the Internet

Now download all the updates while EVERYTHING is blocked from Internet access!

Explain why you think we should trust anyone like that...

and please tell us why YOU would trust them...

I've GOT to hear this!

avatar

cpuking2010

QUIT PIRATING AND OR COMMITTING ILLEGAL ACTS, ON YOUR COMPUTER! Do this and you'll have nothing to worry about.

avatar

Bullwinkle J Moose

QUIT PIRATING AND OR COMMITTING ILLEGAL ACTS, ON YOUR COMPUTER ?

What does that have do do with an Illegal and global spyware operation on EVERYONES computer?

Are you a party to the Illegal Global spyware operation to know what I'm doing or are you just talking shit?

Let's ask ANONYMOUS

avatar

blkpanthr

tra la la la la...where did i put my Lithium?

coocoo...

avatar

Bullwinkle J Moose

Good one

But how do you secure your computer?

More Meds or A Bigger Hat?

avatar

Hey.That_Dude

those of us with significant security issues normally do the most secure thing you can do with a PC.
It's called "unplug". I know it's a strange and foreign concept, but stay with me for part two.

still there, GREAT!
part 2: linux/Unix, free.
nuf said.

avatar

Carlidan

Best advice to give a paranoid person. :)

But how about those magnetic waves they are sending to your brain!

avatar

blkpanthr

Isnt that what my Tinfoil hat is for?

avatar

Carlidan

ARE YOU SURE! :P Me thinks tinfoil hats is a government plan to make people wear tinfoil hats so they CAN read our thoughts!

FYI just poking fun!

avatar

blkpanthr

lol....perhaps...

avatar

chart2006

Can we say Rambus!!! It would be nice to see more standardization but unlikely it will be adopted industry wide. We can hope right!?

avatar

chronium

I wonder if its possible to sue the patent office under the grounds of gross negligence or something. One for a publicity stunt but also to try and force changes in the rules so stupid patents aren't possible to make anymore.

avatar

LatiosXT

The problem with the patent office (if I heard correctly) is that they stopped receiving government funding... so they came up with asinine ways to get more patents in. More patents = fees.

avatar

chart2006

+ Infinity

avatar

Aerumnosus

That Pic is priceless Paul lol. :)

avatar

Ledoubleu

lol Agreed. Best ever contextual pic award!

avatar

Jaeger_CDN

This whole global patent/injunction thing has really gotten out of hand.

It's to the point where I'll stop buying products from companies that insist on playing that game.

avatar

Zoandar

Should be easy to do, since most of today's products come from China, where patents are a big joke.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.