Microsoft Loses $290 Million Patent Appeal, Fails to Shake Up U.S. Patent System



+ Add a Comment


This is ridiculous fucking patent trolls are killing the tech industry.


Anyway in response Microsoft should revoke all Canadian licenses of Office that would be some funny shit.



Microsoft all but admitted that they knowingly stole intellectual property belonging to i4i. They got what they had coming to them; their proverbial dicks slapped into the dirt. Large companies have to learn that they can't just appropriate the technology of smaller companies and think that they can get away with it.



Its much more likely that they didn't and i4i waited 2 years until they could sue for millions to tell them. Thats usually how these patent cases work. The plaintiff realizes someone is using their intellectual property and waits until they generate value with it and then comes the lawsuit. Sadly this activity isn't illegal. The patent system is designed to promote creativity and innovation, but it is seriously stifling the tech industry. Everytime a company wants to create a product it has to vetted incessantly probably still contains some random persons IP. Since the patent system in the US has allowed the patenting of the simplest most inane procedures a computer can do, companies are extremely apprehensive about creating any product that is one pixel or half a procedure close to someones years old IP they no longer use.

How is allowing a company to sit on intellectual property and not use it, "Fostering innovation" as per the design of the patent system.  The current patent system allows tiny coporations to do nothing but gather patents, patent things they never use, or patent the simplest procedure required by so many applications and stifle the entire industry with law suits. Its rare when the big guys are in the right, but if companies like i4i are allowed to continue this activity it will extremely hurt the interests of all members of the tech community even the little developers.



Zomb, nice, thoughtful reply. Thanks.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.