FireWire Still Spreading Like Wild Fire

15

Comments

+ Add a Comment
avatar

QuadraQ

While USB 3.0 is exciting, FireWire kicks all the previous standards to the curb. Best speed, best reliablility, and doesn't slow the rest of your system down because it has it's own controller, and doesn't need the CPU to control it.

avatar

Vigilant Satyr

I've only ever used FW to download video from my Sony digital camcorder into my PC.  Now that I have a new flash memory camcorder/camera as soon as I copy my few remaining tapes over to my PC it may as well be history.

It was decent competition for USB technically and certainly surpassed it initially, but Sony killed it by not actually competing with USB on price just like they did for any number of technologies, Beta, Memory Stick, MiniDisk, et al.

avatar

fellowleo

Been trying to get the Firewire on my Windows 7 HTPC to work with my Cablebox. It used to work on and off with Ubuntu but no luck with Windows 7. Possible for you guys to look into this?

avatar

zblackrider

......

flogging a dead horse.

avatar

SANMANx

All my wife wanted for christmas was for me to transfer our miniDV tapes to our computer. 14 hours later it was done (14 miniDV tapes of home videos). Firewire is great for that format. I have used it alot.

avatar

praetor_alpha

I keep an external hard drive at my parents as an offsite backup. It has Firewire, and is the only Firewire device I have ever had. Got USB 2, Firewire 400, and 800. Yes, Firewire at 400 mbps is faster than USB 2 at 480 mbps.

I see Macbooks with FW 800 ports all the time, but never a PC, whereas PC motherboards have had the same FW 400 ports since about 2003. Are the licensing fees/implementation costs for FW 800 so outrageous that no one has put them as standard on motherboards?

avatar

Xaero429

Since USB is free, and firewire is proprietary to sony, it's an infinite price increase to put a firewire port on a motherboard.  Not only that, but it's very niche, and is basically used for home video, and that's it.  If sony would make firewire ports free, then i would guess people would see a few more pop up.  USB 3.0 is 4.8 Gbps though, and will be the faster choice in the near future.

avatar

Markitzero

I have a FireWire on my PC in the back but I have never used it at all. I mainly use USB 2.0 or the internal Optical drive.

avatar

gothliciouz

what do they mean by " two billion ports"?..as in  you connect 127 divices, using a hub to a single usb port, and in firewire you can get two billions?

avatar

Scootiep

They need to get 1394d standardized and out the door so there's some good competition to USB 3.0. But even after that, I still doubt it will have the popularity of USB 3.0. Kind of sad seeing as how firewire offers a true peer-to-peer network and USB requires a bus master.

avatar

jowens203

Nope.. Haven't seen the 1394 adaptor/port since my iPod circa 2003, and my laptop around the same time. I haven't noticed it being used on any recent vid equipment either.. Does this study include the United States? lol

avatar

OliverSudden

Same here.  Sony video offload to Premiere Pro.  USB's not really an option there.

avatar

strangelove9

I am!

When it comes to offloading digital video from my Sony videocamera, FireWire is still unequalled.

avatar

jowens203

Was just curious.. I don't recall this currently being used on any other vid equipment (i.e. Nikon/ Canon)..

avatar

Athlonite

No it's not and that's because most manufacturers chose USB over firewire

 

and just let it die already I've two on my Asus M3A32MVP-Deluxe (1394a) and I'll more than likely never use them.... my Vantec HDD doc is USB and eSATA my didgital camera is USB my cell phone is USB heck even my 4GB memory stick is yup you guessed it USB, my partners digital photo frames are USB... Infact the only piece of electronics in the house that isn't USB is the satalite DVB box and thats RS232 :S just to make things difacult i spose (there's always one drongo manufacturer)o_O

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.