Facebook Attempts to Outwit Google+ Circles with 'Smart' Friends Filter

4

Comments

Comments are closed on this article

avatar

blindhorizon

while i dont agree or disagree with any of the other posts i have to say the the Friends part of Facebook has been there for about 6 months or more i have been using it.  Mind you its almost imposible to change who is on it cuz like stradric said "unorganized mess of complexity" and i have to agree, but i thought i would mentin that they have had that feature for quite some time now.

avatar

stradric

It's still shit.  This feature is such a hack.  The only thing they're doing is automatically creating the lists for you, but you're still going to have to go through them manually and prune out the "friends" that the algorithm got wrong.

G+ was designed from the get-go around Circles.  One circle is called "friends".  Facebook on the other hand was designed around a "friends list", but most of the people on people's "friends list" aren't actually their friends.   They're just people they may have once known, currently know, currently are friends with or currently stalking.

Not only that, but finding where to edit the Lists in Facebook is still a frustrating experience.  In G+, it's right in your face and core to the UI.

There's also something to be said about the fact that Facebook, once the innovator, is now playing catch up.  They've been hacking features into their UI for so long, that it has become such an unorganized mess of complexity.  G+ keeps it simple, and if they continue to do that, they will eventually overcome Facebook.

avatar

Supall

You can't get rid of Facebook.  For now, I use G+ all the time and (amazingly) mostly for the non-intrusive games and the Sparks feed.  Most of my friends aren't on G+ so I have to keep my Facebook page, but I enjoy the community on it right now (people with a head on their shoulders and aren't spamming the news feed with "OMG!  My butt is so toned right now! [pic]".  So is Facebook's changes something to write home about?  I don't know.  I really don't care anymore what Facebook does so long as it doesn't change my privacy settings.

avatar

spokenwordd

 

There was once a time that you could have said "You can't get rid of MySpace".  Who would have thought back in 2007 that Facebook would be the reigning King and Myspace would be a shell?  I don't believe any social network has a guaranteed life tenure.

 

In my opinion Myspace was a better product had greater privacy and control and I just had a better time on it.  After a short stint on Facebook I refuse to use it for many of the usual reasons.  Namely the drama of seperating certain communications from groups of people that are all assumed to be my "friends".

 

Google + is far from perfect but I can definitely say I enjoy it and look forward to a public release to see if it'll draw me back to social media as a time expenditure.

 

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.