Is Alpha Protocol an Example of DRM Done Right?

13

Comments

+ Add a Comment
avatar

aviaggio

What if they decide to NOT remove the DRM two years later? What recourse do we have? NONE.

So they sell the game based upon the idea the DRM will be removed at some point and then when the time comes they announce they've changed their minds.

Sorry, but I simply don't trust any company that makes future promises like this. 

avatar

snapple00

Haha. It's just a game man.

It sounds like gaming is more of a way of life for you if you are having trust issues with a company.

avatar

hades_2100

This is how Bioshock worked. You had a fixed number of activations. If you uninstalled, you got the activation back.

 

So what's the big deal?

avatar

Zallomallo

My ideal DRM would be either no cd or no internet.  If you do not have the CD then a one-time internet check is used on startup.  If the CD is there then no problems.  Also make it minimal CD checking, not auditing your PC processes for iso stuff.

I mean really the best way to stop piracy is not to cripple videogames, it's to go after distribution.  What they are doing with taking down websites is great.  This way the source of torrenting is taken down, not game quality, or that 60-year-old man who downloaded twelve songs off the internet.

Just my 2 cents. 

avatar

omen3330

I completely agree with your method. I also feel that the developer should offer incentives for registering your game like the Cerberus network in ME2. Sometimes I forget to take a disk to a LAN or just don't feel like poping one in.

avatar

Elric

This might be one case where the DRM is actually better than the game. :)

 

Some of the trailers for this game have me wondering just how bad it's going to be but another part of me wants to buy it just to say "I support SANE DRM".

 

avatar

HeartBurnKid

That depends... does it install malware that usurps your CD-ROM drivers and bitches about .iso mounting tools (i.e. SecuROM)?

avatar

Chef098

This has already been done... Battlefield Bad Company 2 had the same DRM structure. Are we patting sega's back for coming up with this idea or not going down the Ubisoft Assassins Creed 2 DRM death grip?

avatar

IFLATLINEI

This is how it should be done. We all want our favorite developers to protect their work but not at the expense of the people using it. We should never have to even think about it. This is a great solution . Now theres only one thing left. Make sure the game is still playable online with friends when the servers get taken offline. This can be done with some dedicated server software gamers can run on their own extra PC's

avatar

isamuelson

This is exactly what Ubisoft should have done.

Excellent job. It's non-intrusive and it also takes into account two very important factors:

  1.  Those who don't have internet access although limited installs still suck, but at least you have the ability to install it. This is kind of like how Battlefield: Bad Company 2 works. You could install it and use CD check with unlimited installs or else, install with no cd check but with 10 installs.
  2. They promise to remove the DRM 18-24 months later. This is what 2k did with the first BioShock.

I sure hope other companies follow this approach because I will purchase their software with this kind of DRM.

 

avatar

ShadowDragoonFTW

If you ask me, this is a MUCH better solution. I think it's downright perfect (or as close to perfection as the video game industry will ever get). Simple, intuitive, and not overbearing.

avatar

festiva_man

I really appreciate this kind of thinking.  They know that they can't beat pirates and they only hurt consumers using intrusive DRM.  Go Sega.  Now, make another damn console.  Dreamcast was superior and so was the genesis.  You guys rock.

avatar

skiwolf7

You should've added the neon lights.  That was way to subtle for the idiots at Ubisoft to actually catch it.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.