Quantcast

Don't have an account? Register Now! Forgot password?

Maximum IT
Reviews

hField Technologies Wi-Fire Wi-Fi Adapter

comment Commentsprint Printemail EmailDeliciousDiggStumbleUponRedditFacebookSlashdot

We sometimes get so caught up in the excitement of the “next big thing” we throw the baby out with the bathwater. Based on the performance of the Wi-Fire Wi-Fi adapter, that might just be the case with IEEE 802.11g wireless routers.

If you value range over throughput, this is the Wi-Fi adapter for you. This ungainly device doesn’t rely on MIMO or IEEE 8011.n; heck, it doesn’t even require a PCMCIA slot. When we plugged it into our notebook’s USB 2.0 port, it delivered unbelievable range with a year-old Asus WL700gE router equipped with a single antenna.

Indoors, the Wi-Fire performed no better than Linksys’s WPC600N adapter, and no 802.11g router can match the maximum throughput of an 802.11n model. But the Wi-Fire lived up to its name when we moved the notebook outdoors, delivering TCP throughput of 15Mb/s (compared to just 2.7Mb/s for the Linksys).

Our jaws really dropped as we moved the notebook ever further away: 350 feet from the router, with the signal passing through an insulated, double-thick interior wall and a steel garage door, the Wi-Fire delivered TCP throughput of 14.5Mb/s. Maximum range dropped to 135 feet on the other side of the house (which added four insulated interior walls, a set of plywood cabinets, and an insulated exterior wall with fiber-cement siding), but throughput remained steady at 13.2Mb/s.

The antenna is extremely directional, which wouldn’t be a problem if it weren’t mounted so loosely to its plastic stand. You can set it on a tabletop or clip it to your notebook screen, but after you’ve painstakingly located the reception sweet spot, the simple act of breathing is enough to move it out of position. We completely lost our connection only when it pivoted at extreme range, but at no point was the fit sufficiently tight to keep the antenna stationary.

Click to Enlarge

The Wi-Fire's range is flat-out amazing, but the antenna's cheap mounting stand cost it a Kick Ass award.

Wi-Fire Wi-Fi Adapter
www.hfield.com
plus
Old Spice

Unbelievable range. Best through-put at range, bar none.

minus
Old Hat

Very directionally-finicky. Can't compete with Draft-N at short range (obviously). Flimsy base denies it a Kick Ass.

verdict:9
Benchmarks
  Linksys
WCP600N/ Linksys WRT600N
Linksys
WCP600N/ Asus WL700GE
Wi-Fire / Asus WL700GE
Home Office, 5 feet (Mb/s) 129.0 20.9 20.8
Kitchen, 20 feet (Mb/s) 117.0
20.9 21.0
Patio, 38 feet (Mb/s) 114.0
20.8 20.8
Bedroom, 60 feet (Mb/s) 117.0 16.9 18.4
Media Room, 35 feet (Mb/s) 117.0 13.0 15.8
Outdoors A, 90 feet (Mb/s) 2.5 2.7 15.2
Outdoors B, 85 feet (Mb/s) 1.1 3.4 15.1
Outdoors C, 130 feet (Mb/s) no connection no connection 13.2
Outdoors D, 350 feet (Mb/s) no connection no connection 14.5

Best scores are bolded. See here for detailed test criteria.

COMMENTS
avatarWiFire works amazingly well; model 200 now has excellent mount

Because I travel within the USA a great deal, I've needed a more powerful WiFi antennae when searching for hotspots -- mainly so I do NOT have to get out of my vehicle (and go inside a business) just to get online.  

Amazingly, the WiFire does exactly that.  Even better, when I've paid for WiFi at truck stops, their signal can be so weak that I literally had to go inside their restaurant to get WiFi service.  Now I can park along the side of an Interstate near a truck stop, hotel, coffee shop or some free hotspot, and the WiFire signal is better than their parking lot, and as good as inside the building.  WiFire saves me time, money, and grief, so it is well worth the price.  It works great on my MacBook Pro (intel cpu) whether I'm running under MS Windows XP or Apple OS X Leopard.  I also sometimes use it on my older PowerBook with the same excellent results.  The software they provide is very helpful too.

WiFire simply works great.  

I recommend it to anyone, especially travelers -- auto, RV, truck, whatever ! 

Login or register to post comments
avatarProduct = Waste of money, do not get scammed.

Bought this piece of junk a little over a year ago so I could use it to sapposably connect to wifi signals farther away... What a joke. If you are like me & do not connect to your own wifi signal & use wifi on other peoples unsecure routers, this product is NOT for you. First off, they tell you that you must point it directly towards the router, which I have tested with my own router I had. I lost connection after walking to the end of my driveway. (Which by the way I WAS pointing the Wi-Fire directly towards my router, not to mention my driveway is about 100 feet from my house) I told Wi-Fire about the issue & they responded, telling me that I had to point it towards the router (Which I just mentioned that I did) so they were useless.. I decided to just say Fk it & forget about it. I took it apart & all Wi-Fire is, is a blank Component board with a thin copper lining... They use cheap parts & sell their product for $80-$100. I have had better luck with Linksys products (Which I was using before I had bought Wi-Fire in HOPES that perhaps it would work better, but did absolutly nothing except empty my pockets negative $80. Trust me, you do NOT want this, Please, try to find another solution, or save your money, you will regret it...

 

                                                                                                    -Unhappy Customer

Login or register to post comments
avatarProduct sux0rz

Product does NOT receive my seal of approval. I did not find any of the range and throughput benefits that MPC found. Not sure if my unit was defective (it didn't really appear "factory fresh" and could have been someone else's return), but I would not recommend this product.

-[Ch]ams

Login or register to post comments
avatarwonderful service

I'd like to throw this info out as I'm sure most company's get bashed for poor service. When the opposite is true we should let others know. I had purchased the Wi-Fire last year and was perfectly happy with it when used on 2 different older laptops. Recently I sold both of these and got a new Inspiron 1525 with Vista. The Wi-Fire would not work even with software updates from hField's site. I emailed customer service and got an immediate response. After several questions they told me I'd have to upgrade to the newest model which would be $20 when exchanging the old model. I ordered the new one with the coupon code they gave me and was prepared to ship the old so the new would be sent when they received it. Lo and behold 2 days after posting the transaction I got the new model without returning the old yet...I'll be sure to send it out immediately. I appreciate their wonderful service. By the way the new model works even better. tnx, John

Login or register to post comments
This Month's Issue
FEATURE Windows XP/Vista/7 Tips!FEATURE Monitor Roundup: 7 LCDs ReviewedHOW TOMaster PhotoshopFEATUREAMD's Awesome New GPUWHITE PAPEROrganic LEDs