WoW Lead: PC “Re-Emerging” Because of Complexity – Not Despite It
The rumors of our humble Greatest Platform in the World's death may have been greatly exaggerated, but the causes of its recent “resurrection” are a bit muddled. Typically, though, we get a repetitive song-and-dance composed of echoing praises for social gaming and a slide-to-jazz-hands flourish that's somehow supposed to represent casual titles and simpler interfaces. That's a double-edged sword if we've ever seen one. World of Warcraft lead developer Tom Chilton, however, isn't ready to let the Farmvilles of the world turn PC into their infinitely milkable cash cow just yet. Complexity, he says, is actually a selling point.
“In a lot of ways I see the PC as potentially a re-emerging sort of platform,” Chilton told PC Gamer. “I think that the PC has always offered ways to approach games that you can’t necessarily approach on console, even if it’s just because of UI restraints.”
“Keyboard and mouse opens up options that you can’t get replicate as easily with a controller in RTS games like Starcraft 2. If you look at the way we do an MMO like World of Warcraft, our communication method and all that kind of stuff, it kind of implies a level of UI complexity that would be really hard to pull off on console. I think that combined with the digital distribution in a lot of ways has the potential to me to make the PC a really strong gaming platform going into the future,” he concluded.
The man has a point. Say what you will about Blizzard, but its games work like a charm on PC and PC alone. Sadly, though, it's the exception – not the rule – in the big-budget sector. Console ports rule the roost, and then they venture beyond it and fight, like, a lion or something just 'cause. Here's hoping Chilton's right, and that trend turns around in a big way. Because seriously, if we can't obsessively hotkey every action in existence, what's even the point?
Comments
Comments are closed on this article
![]()
francisco6007
September 02, 2011 at 7:33am
yea the consoles are six years old. but a computer with decent 6 year old hardware can still beat it in gaming if set right...
![]()
Thresher
September 02, 2011 at 6:23am
The only thing that keeps a console from being able to replicate the experience of a PC is that Microsoft will not allow keyboards and mice as controllers for XBox games. Sony sort of does.
There is nothing stopping MS and Sony from allowing keyboard+mouse control, and if that happened, then PC gaming would truly be hurt.
![]()
compro01
September 02, 2011 at 7:05am
Hurt by people fumbling to use a keyboard+mouse on the couch?
Or are they going to set up the Xboxes at a desk and use them as psudo-PCs?
![]()
Thresher
September 02, 2011 at 11:09am
Why not? I game at my desk, regardless of format. I suspect quite a few people do.
![]()
reutnes
September 02, 2011 at 1:16pm
My xbox doubles as a monitor stand. I'm not sure if I get what the OP's main point is. What do couches have to do with anything? I use both my console and my pc pretty heavily.
![]()
bpstone
September 02, 2011 at 4:15am
At the moment developers are limited to an outdated API with consoles. Some are aiming toward PC hardware again as it continues to become more complex with modern APIs. The next lineup of consoles will probably start being released in 2012-2014 and grab their attention back in that direction again. Until game piracy can be greatly reduced without it being inconvenient to their customers, PC gaming isn't going to explode onto the gaming scene anytime soon. You'll still see plenty of titles for it nonetheless.
![]()
Gezzer
September 02, 2011 at 2:05am
Sometimes the whole "the PC is dieing", "tablets are the next big thing", "social gaming is the new money maker" and rhetoric of this nature reminds me of the wizard of Oz. You know, the guy trying to make everyone see him as great and wise when really it was all a front.
Is the market changing? Of course. Are there more platforms to splinter the market? Well duh. The amount of times PCs in general and gaming on PCs in particular have been written off is mind boggling when you consider how often it's come true.
I think all these nay sayers think they can't be wrong all the time. But the way I see it every market will expand and contract over time, even reinvent it's self once or twice. So will PC gaming change? Sure. Will it die? Never. A PC is just too versatile not too be able to weather any storm coming, so of course we'll see a rebound in the PC market after a slump.
I'd be really surprised if the gaming PC was always the dominate platform. Just like how surprised I'd be if it really did die off. Neither one will ever happen.
![]()
Holly Golightly
September 02, 2011 at 12:58am
I am glad to see PC gaming on the rise.
Consoles have become that new middle ground. Not enough graphical power to wow anybody, not cool enough like a tablet. Basically... Consoles are like laptops... This useless medium. Why would anybody want to be caught with an outdated piece of hardware, when you can get better stuff for a competitive price or performance that can wow the hell out of everybody. There is just no point in staying at that middle ground.
Plus, consoles are known to get Red Rings (Xbox360) Yellow Lights (PS3) and Black Screens (DS) of death. Therefore you got to get a second one... This makes the PC Gaming platform offer more bang for your buck. The complexity of PCs allows us the luxury to play videogames that date as far back as the DOS era, to the upcoming Windows 8 era. Now that is quality we can all trust. Lets not forget all of the emulators of classic consoles available at our hands. Good times I must say.
So I do agree, PC gaming is on the rise due to this freedom, power, and yes, complexity. Thank goodness!
![]()
Vernak
September 01, 2011 at 11:36pm
Captain Palette Swap talking about complexity? Really? The PC Gamer interviewer should have rolled up their own magazine and smacked Ghostcrawler upside the head with it.
![]()
SeverianSilk
September 01, 2011 at 10:53pm
This is sort of what I've been on about the whole time. There's a market for PCs out there and it's pretty significant. Companies, such as Microsoft and others, need to stop trying to corner every bit of market that becomes the latest fad (ahem... tablets... ahem) and focuse on their core audience. They'll end up being much more successfull if they continue to focus on what they're good at and who their biggest supporters are instead of spreading themselves out too thin with things they're not meant to do. There's a PC market out there, and if you focus on it (if you're already a giant in that industry) you'll be much better off than focusing on something you're not (i.e. HP pulling out because of the iPad). The PC market is alive and well, and if that's your forte, stick to it. Stop chasing fads. Worst business decision ever.
/rant
![]()
TheElite1x721987
September 01, 2011 at 8:54pm
sadly, I agree. The current console hardware is losing steam at this point (from a technological standpoint). It's at this time that lots of gamers will flock back to PC as the current consoles now have a hard time "wowing" people anymore. In a couple years time when all the next gen consoles are released we will probably see things sink right back to the way they were. I don't want that to happen, but we all know it will.
![]()
Arclite
September 01, 2011 at 8:36pm
It could also do with the fact that current console hardware is six years old...
![]()
p47riot
September 02, 2011 at 10:35am
Well, if you're comparing the latest console to the latest PC hardware, your statement might work on the surface. But back it up 6 years and compare the two and see how they weather the test of time. I built my current gaming PC 6 years ago. In that time, I've made all sorts of upgrades to the RAM, CPU, Storage, OS, and various other tweaks to keep it up with the times. These kinds of upgrades are severely limited on a console, if altogether impossible. As such, I can run everything (that's worth playing) at decent framerates at 1920x1080x32. Clearly, the PC is the more complex and versatile platform. The fact that consoles are for the most part stuck with the hardware they are built with only proves this.
With that said, I love console gaming for it's accessibility. My kids and I enjoy playing Wii together, which is the most obsolete "current" console out there. Sometimes simplicity is the best solution.
Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook
Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.
















