Quantcast

Don't have an account? Register Now! Forgot password?

Maximum IT
Features

Build the Perfect PC! Step-by-Step Illustrated How-To Guide

comment Commentsprint Printemail EmailDeliciousDiggStumbleUponRedditFacebookSlashdot

CPU Cooler Buyers Guide

Overclocking? A great heatsink and fan will help you avoid a fried CPU

By David Murphy

You can’t just eyeball a cooler. The size of a fan doesn’t dictate its capacity for chilling your processor. We’ve tested huge models that do anything but, and we’ve put our hands on smaller devices that have blown the heat right out of our test rig. The only true way to evaluate a cooler’s prowess is to strap it over the top of your CPU and test it. But that’s easier said than done.

Here are a few tips to steer you in the right thermal direction. For starters, you should consider the total amount of heat dissipation a cooler has to offer, versus its actual ability to cool. What the heck does that mean?

A cooler with a great mass fins will heat up more slowly than one with equipped with less surface area for dissipating heat. But you need more than fins to prevent your processor from overheating; you must also consider the cooler’s fan’s capacity for drawing air over those fins. 

A big, bulky cooler with lots of fins trades size for noise reduction, because it can use a a fan that spins at low RPM. A cooler with  less surface area will fit in a smaller enclosure and is less likely to interfere with other components inside the case, but it will need a fan that spins much faster in order to pull in enough air. But a rapidly spinning fan can turn a quiet PC into a wind tunnel.

A cooling solution that combines lots of fins with a powerful fan will deliver the best of both worlds. You can easily quiet your PC by dialing back the fan speed in the BIOS, but you’ll never squeeze the best performance out of your CPU using an underwhelming cooler.

Alpine 7 Pro

Look no further for a gentle upgrade over your stock Intel cooler


Given its small size, we didn’t expect maximum cooling performance from Arctic Cooling’s Alpine 7 Pro. And while the Alpine 7 Pro doesn’t set any performance records, in some situations it does match the capabilities of our cooler of choice, Thermaltake’s DuOrb. Given the sheer size difference between this 9x9x3cm cooler and the, well, monstrous DuOrb, the Alpine 7’s performance was a pleasant surprise.

The Alpine 7 Pro does an exceptional job of cooling when your processor is idle—it even ran head to head with the DuOrb in this capacity. Both coolers dropped the temperature of all four cores of our Q6700 to 36 C, but when we cranked up our processor to 100 percent usage rates, the Alpine 7 faltered.

Click here to read the rest of the review!

Thermaltake DuOrb

This figure eight is great! 

Zalman’s CNPS9700 has been the Godzilla of coolers and a Best of the Best champion for more than a year. But it’s finally facing its Megalon in Thermaltake’s DuOrb cooler.

Unlike the CNPS9700, which has an 11cm fan strapped to the side of its imposing copper and aluminum frame, the DuOrb’s heatsinks are stretched out horizontally. The extra-wide cooler, shaped in a 20-centimeter-wide figure eight, comes with two 8cm blue and red LED fans tucked inside two rings of copper fins.

Click here to read the rest of the review!

Zalman CNPS9300 AT

Big power in a tiny package 


Zalman CNPS9300 AT - click for full!


When we first got our hands on Zalman’s CNPS9300 AT, we assumed that the company had pulled a “Honey, I Shrunk the CPU Cooler” on its flagship product, the bulky CNPS9700. The CNPS9300 is 80 percent smaller, and its total thermal dissipation area has been nearly halved, from 5,490cm2 to 2,583cm2.

Logic dictates that this cooler should perform far worse than the CNPS9700. But the built-for-silence CNPS9300 AT nearly matches its big brother’s performance—as well as that of our top cooler, Thermaltake’s DuOrb.

Click here to read the rest of the review!

Cooler Master V8

A healthy cup of cooling for your CPU

Cooler Master’s V8 CPU cooler ameliorates a somewhat time-consuming installation process with near-record-setting performance for an air cooler. The sleek aluminum cooler’s 12cm fan sits between two heatsinks on the device, sparing fingers from the accidental nip of its 800rpm to 1,800rpm variable fan.

The V8’s installation process is similar to that of most other CPU coolers, but with a few more screws involved. On an Intel platform, you start by attaching two retention plates to the cooler itself. You then remove the motherboard from your case and flip it upside-down, matching the ends of the cooler’s four retention screws with the mobo’s holes. You balance this contraption in your lap while using four large nuts to secure this beast of a device in place. You can also use an included backplane to mount the device, but we found the nut method to be far easier.

Click here to read the rest of the review!

Case Buyers Guide

These enclosures lend new meaning to the phrase “boom box”

By David Murphy

When we review a case, we take the time to build out a complete system: installing everything from the motherboard to the videocard and power supply. In our view, that’s the only valid means of assessing an enclosure’s merits and shortcomings.

Manufacturers invest big bucks designing the exteriors of their products, adding lights, motorized doors, and other (sometimes goofy) features in an effort to make their box stand apart on crowded store shelves. But you’ll curse every ounce of that bling while you’re building and every time you go back to tweak, upgrade, or plug in a component if they didn’t dedicate just as much attention to crucial details such as drive bays and mounts, the power-supply rack, air flow, front-panel connections (for eSATA, USB, Firewire, and audio), accommodations for air and liquid cooling, and other bread-and-butter features.

That’s not to say that an excellent case should be ugly; after all, it’s your rig’s most visible attribute. Indeed, the cases that earn Maximum PC’s coveted KickAss award are enclosures that manage to strike that delicate balance between form and function, beauty and utility, elegance and ruggedness.

Gigabyte Poseidon 310

Raise a trident in honor of this chassis


Instead of a god of the sea, Gigabyte’s midtower Poseidon 310 chassis is a petite prince. But that’s merely a reflection of this case’s size, not its prowess. It weighs in at 7.75”x17”x20”—small enough to fit into that nook in your desk or the space under your bed.

Even given its small size, the Poseidon supports up to five 5.25-inch devices. We’re unsure why this case—or any case, for that matter—still bothers with multiple external 3.5-inch bays. You get two helpings of them on the Poseidon. We would have rather sacrificed these and an additional 5.25-inch bay in favor of more internal hard drive space.

Click here to read the rest of the review!

CoolerMaster HAF

This is the new case to beat for air-cooling aficionados

Cooler Master’s newest HAF (High Air Flow) chassis is the company’s magnum opus, successfully unifying the best elements from various previous efforts. Event better, the HAF features a number of new features that raise the bar for case design. 

Case cooling is the HAF’s centerpiece. Three 23cm fans at the top, front, and side of the HAF circulate air even when running at just 700rpm, balancing air flow with acceptable noise levels.

Click here to read the rest of the review! 

Silverstone Kublai KL03

No stately pleasure dome this

The Kublai KL03 offers a hodgepodge of features that Silverstone never manages to get just right.

Take the  giant horizontal retention bar, for example. It supports two 12cm fans (which aren’t included) and comes with a number of sliding bars for holding your PCI-based components in place. But the retention bar, which must be screwed down to stay in place, did little to support our test rig’s guts.

Click here to read the rest of the review! 

In Win B2

Tower, this is Ghost Rider requesting a fly-by

In Win B2 Chassis - click for full!

In Win can’t resist building gimmicks into its chassis. The company’s B2 isn’t quite as ostentatious—unless you think the motorized front panel is over the top.

This midtower chassis does, however, take its B2 theme to extreme levels. The vent on the case’s snap-locking side panel looks like a Stealth bomber and the case’s exterior is peppered with aeronautical jargon. We love the look, but working in this case is a different story.

Click here to read the rest of the review!

Koolance PC4-1025BK

Awesome cooling isn’t enough to make this case awesome

Koolance’s PC4-1025BK seems like a perfect power-user box, until you realize that this water-cooling-enriched case is just too small for enthusiast hardware.

A water-cooling mechanism is integrated into the chassis: Koolance’s KIT-1000KB cooler, a tri-fan setup that comes with a front-mounted controller for the fans’ speeds. The whole getup is a tidy little package that cools monstrously even when using the quietest mode the PC4-1025BK offers.

Click here to read the rest of the review!

COMMENTS
avatarPrice/performance comparison?

I'd like to see a price performance ratio with NewEgg or Pricewatch or some other source to get at performance.  AMD usually wins price/performance but the cheap quads Intel put out challenged that notion.

I also wanna know, just for kicks, when is Microsoft or Apple going to start optimizing their software (OS and applications) for 64 bit and for multi-core processors?  Isn't a lot of what the chip makers putting out being simply wasted because only Adobe and a few others have bothered to optimize their software for multicore? Games might be a lot faster if they used more than one core, and its been a few years now, right?  Shouldn't something in the development pipeline be able to take advantage of 2+ cores and rock out with its code out?

Login or register to post comments
avatarI totally agree

I totally agree.   Are there ANY games out there that can take advantage of 2 cores or more?  If not, then why should I buy anything more than a high end Core 2 Duo and put the money towards a kickass videocard, maybe 2,  and/or maybe even a PCI-Express SoundBlaster?  Just some food for thought.

Sincerely yours, from Fort Campbell, KY,

SGT Samuel E. McClard II

Life's a journey, enjoy the ride!!

Login or register to post comments
avatar.

you should have used Ph2 720. Stick a better Video card in the rig with the saved money. Much better frame rate improvement.

Login or register to post comments
avatarzalman 9900?

wheres the new zalman cooler at? its your best tested cooler, so its kinda funny you dont recommend it for building a pc. plus the zalman 9900 is getting unfairly beaten over the head on newegg by stupid reviewers, i hate people sometimes. great article though, very informative and lengthy, ill definitely recommend people new to building pc's to this.

Login or register to post comments
avatarMemory Boo Boo

I spy an error!  When talking about the official supported memory speed of the Core i7, it should read DDR3/1333 which is PC3 10666 not 1066.

Login or register to post comments
avatarI agree with da_saman...I

I agree with da_saman...I believe the build-your-own pc guide should have been revised with the new parts which present a different build experience altogether. I also noticed a lot of the writing about "why we chose the parts" was also from the article in an old issue. I do, however, commend you guys for a great overview of the parts out today and how to get the maximum potential out of your pc.

Login or register to post comments
avatarNew guide, old info

The actual section where you build the rig looks like it is utilizing the old guide where they used the Stacker case.  Shouldn't the pictures and the writing reflect the new parts? 

Sincerely yours, from Ft. Campbell, KY,

SGT Samuel E. McClard II

Life's a journey, enjoy the ride!!

Login or register to post comments
avatarMicroCenter....

I just learned about them, love their deals-saving a lot on my case and the Core i7 920....but they never get new stock. I have been waiting almost a week, going on 2 for them to get more Core i7s because they are out of stock right now. Many places get new stuff on Tuesdays....doesn't seem to be the deal here.

Login or register to post comments
avatarNCIX

Give NCIX a try, if you're in the US here is the URL:

http://www.ncixus.com/

If in Canada (which is where I am):

http://www.ncix.com/

There prices are a bit more expensive, but they do price matching...so you're able to get cheaper prices; also they tend to do surprise sales, etc.

Michael

Login or register to post comments
avatarLooks like they took it off.

Looks like they took it off. They don't have the banner ad for it, and looking at the "processors" section shows nothing.

Login or register to post comments
avatarMicrocenter has i7 for $229

Microcenter has i7 920 for $229 right now...you cant go wrong! 02/11/2009

2/12/09 - Looks like it is off the website search...odd. I bought mine about 3 weeks ago when I got the ad in an email. Paid $229 for it - couldnt believe it!

I found the link http://www.microcenter.com/single_product_results.phtml?product_id=0300438

Also to their ad this month is BYOPC: http://microcenter.com/specials/catalogs/broadsheet.html

Login or register to post comments
avatarSome things I felt were

Some things I felt were missing:

1. AMD's Phenom II (Deneb)

2. More AMD boards

3. A Thermalright HSF

4. One of Antec's gaming cases (like the 902 or 1200)

Login or register to post comments
avatarThis should have been

This should have been called, "Build the Perfect Intel Based PC"

Login or register to post comments

This Month's Issue
FEATURE How to Get FREE Programs, Services, Software & MoreFEATURE Digital Photo Printer RoundupHOW TOBuild a 3D CameraFEATUREDIY Arcade PCWHITE PAPERHow TRIM Works