ATI to Nvidia: You're a Dinosaur
On the eve of the GeForce GTX 280 launch just last week, ATI unveiled a bombshell—a brand-new GPU architecture that utilized better process technology and a more power efficient design to outperform Nvidia's gargantuan new GPU. ATI eschewed the huge, hot monolithic GPU for a more compact, but modular core. With twin goals of decreased power consumption and more efficiency per die area, ATI looks poised to dethrone Nvidia, and all without building a videocard that sports an aural footprint roughly equivalent to a Dyson vacuum cleaner.
With the new RV770 GPU comes two products, the $200 Radeon 4850 and the $300 Radeon 4870. While their prices vary wildly, the videocards all use the same GPU. Let’s find out what makes it tick.
Under the Heat Spreader
ATI says the day of the giant monolithic GPU is over. Instead of using giant, power-hungry GPUs, ATI is planning on designing smaller, more efficient GPUs that can work together to handle big workloads.
We’ve walked this path before. When Intel’s Netburst architecture reached the end of its life, we were seeing the largest, hottest, most power-hungry CPUs ever, but performance wasn’t scaling up as fast as the power and heat were. In order to see a 10% performance increase, the new CPU would generate 30% more heat and require 30% more power. This was an untenable situation, so Intel and AMD quickly moved away from monolithic cores to more efficient multi-core designs. If your applications can take advantage of all the CPU cores in your system, you should see significantly better performance with a much slower, cooler multi-core design than you would with a similar sized single-core design running at twice the speed.
The two main GPU manufacturers are at a similar crossroads, and each chose a different direction with this generation of GPU. Nvidia has launched its GTX 280 boards, which sport a massive monolithic GPU design. These are among the largest chips ever put into mass production—a single GTX 280 chip is 576mm^2, features a 512-bit memory interface, and draws 236W when it’s running at full bore. To contrast, the RV770 chip that ATI is using in its new line of GPUs is just 260mm^2, features a 256-bit memory bus, and draws about 170W when running at full bore. But, despite a much smaller die, drawing less power, and running a memory bus about half the width of the GTX 280, the Radeon 4870 delivers about 75% of the speed of the faster card in most of our benchmarks.