The Game Boy: Why Transmedia Gaming's Totally Missing The Point

avatar

The Game Boy: Why Transmedia Gaming's Totally Missing The Point

In truth, though, the corporate convolution of it all is only part of the problem. Do I want to, say, poke and prod at tiny, previously unknown corners of Dead Space and Mass Effect's universes while on the go? Sure. Sounds like a nice vacation within my vacation. Nowadays, though, that simply can't be a reward in and of itself. I'm beginning to think publisher execs believe gamers hate to actually play games, because everything dangles some oh-so-desirable carrot in front of our noses. Ghost Recon: Commander, for instance, will reward your tactical Facebook exploits with weapons in Ghost Recon: Future Soldier and Ghost Recon Online – and vice versa. 

The biggest offender, though, is easily Mass Effect 3. Its Galactic Readiness means that multiplayer and iOS spin-off Mass Effect: Infiltrator directly (and confusingly) impact single-player. No, you don't need to play either to get an optimal ending, but the game strongly encourages it without really explaining how to make up for it if you don't. Both Mass Effect and (to a lesser extent) Ghost Recon introduce a slimy strand of obligation to their proceedings. Hell, Mass Effect's Galactic Readiness degrades over time, essentially pressuring players into brittle bundles of nerves and stress over their game experience. 

I really shouldn't need to be saying this, but here goes: Gaming is a leisure activity. We don't play these things to be strong-armed into sacrificing our precious hours at the almighty alter of transmedia. You know what obligation is? It's a product of real life and all the ugly pressures I play games to get away from. I can't lose myself in a fantasy world if you're constantly punching me in the face with brass knuckles made from the real one. I want to love this magnificent place you've constructed, held on high by the carpel-tunnel-ridden claws of writers who poured their passion onto a page until they bled. I really, really do. But you make it so damn hard. 

And that's a crying shame, because – in theory – transmedia's a pretty rad idea. So please, publishers, stop breaking its bones to fit an obtuse monetary mold. For one, no one cares, so that's gonna hurt your bottom line a bit. But, more importantly, these worlds are at their best when both they and their players can do what they want, when they want. Believe it or not, people like to explore and discover. It lets us own an experience, world, or brand. (Or, put another way, do you think Star Wars Extended Fiction novels sell because they're good? Hah!) So quit suffocating us. It's time for a breath of fresh air.

10

Comments

+ Add a Comment
avatar

someuid

When I built a new computer last winter for my wife, the video card came with a free copy of Dirt 3. After getting through the whole Live account setup (see http://techreport.com/discussions.x/22085) and finally got the game up and running, I saw all the on-line integration to share your scores, replays, stats, cars, etc.

I exited the game without even giving it a try. My wife never tried it either. Their entire intro was about how I can share everything I do with the world to see how stack up. F' that. I have better things to do.

Does this bother me? No. It simply highlights to me those companies that are run by business managers who's choices are made based upon the profit column in their spreadsheet, not the content or quality of the game. Hence I know to go look elsewhere.

Does this mean I'm playing the latest and greatest triple A title? No. And that is ok. It means I get to play the games I end up really liking, because I picked a game from a studio that was interested in actually making a game, rather than measuring some pointless statistic like "# of likes on facebook". I've no interest in keeping up with the jones at work who play the newest release of a game. They aren't really game players anyway. Get one of them into a serious game like skirmishes in Company of Heroes vs experts and you quickly see how poor they are at playing a video game to start with.

Good article Nathan. In the future, when you and the other editors are reviewing a game, please be sure to mention "riddled with facebook and Live integration" so I know to avoid it, or at least expect it when I install it (if I do.)

avatar

slibinz

Agreed. I'm the only person in my RIFT guild who doesn't have a smartphone (sorry, but I can barely afford the $15/month just to play, let alone a new phone + data plan) and every single day I fall behind them a little more, because they can use the RIFT Mobile App to get in-game rewards that I cannot.

As if people aren't tied (no, frak that, SURGICALLY CONNECTED) to their phones enough as it is....

I couldn't agree with the article's author enough. Games should be a stand-alone escape from your life. This transmedia crap just smacks of desperation to me. You don't always have to be a part of the "next big thing", just do what you do WELL and you'll always be successful.

avatar

flyup

Here are some brass knuckles made from the real world.

Devil's Advocate: If you were a patriot then you wouldn't be slandering transmedia. It's one of gamings finest barriers in piracy. Sharing character and stats across platforms is a stick in the mud for pirates.

On selecting "how's your family"- I select this option because I want to ferret out all the hot 'love' scenes. I feel like that's a romantic thing to say to my female crew members. Okay, I say it to the males too--- And the Aliens!!! Transmedia baby!

avatar

Matarsak

Altar. The almighty ALTAR of transmedia.

avatar

dgrmouse

I suspect that I'd agree with the general sentiment of this article if I could tell what the heck the author was talking about. Try reading this article as if you had never played the games in question and had no idea what a transmedia is. It's a pretty major failure.

avatar

Ghok

I thought the same thing, dgrmouse. I'm pretty sure I agree with the article in question, but I didn't really understand a lot of what was being talked about without making a lot of assumptions. Fair enough, since I never played the games in question.

avatar

Raswan

You, unlike the author of the article here, clearly never read any books in high school, because your reading comprehension sucks balls. You can't engage with the thesis because the particulars he's referencing are outside of the scope of your personal experience? Please.

Great article Nathan. As always, well-written (though I think you're getting a little attached to ctrl+B; don't worry, you're a good enough writer that we'll get the point on our own), interesting, and full of wit. You, Chacos, and Lilly are the stylistic glue holding this website together. Keep up the good work.

avatar

DanQuixote

"Donny, you're out of your element."

I don't know if I would go so far as to call the article a failure. For someone who has never heard of the games mentioned and has no idea what transmedia is, I guess it would be difficult to deduce the purpose of this article. Just as if I were to read an article about quantum physics (which I know very little about), I would probably have a hard time trying to figure out what the heck it was talking about. I would also have a hard time judging the merits of the article given my lack of knowledge. For a lot of articles, especially on this website, you need some sort of background knowledge or frame of reference to understand what is being said.

You are obviously entitled to your opinion. However, I think that this article speaks to many gamers, like myself, who have played these games and can relate to the frustration of seemingly required extracurricular game shenanigans.

avatar

DanQuixote

Great article! I'm glad someone has finally spoken up to address this awful aspect of modern games. While playing through the Mass Effect 3 single player campaign, I felt that playing multiplayer was almost like homework. While the multiplayer is fun, it felt more like a chore playing game after game to get my galactic readiness up before completing the final mission of the game, and don't even get me started on iOS spin-offs.

avatar

LatiosXT

Now that you mention it, I'm going to start groaning every time I see something out of place happening.

Like last night I beat Alan Wake for the PC. However I think I never really experienced what the game was really like because of shallow rewards that they were offering me for doing things in the game. Collect the coffee thermos! Do something in x amount of time! Kill x amount of Taken with a weapon!

In fact, when I was looking at one for defeating the final boss in under a minute thirty, I had to get a grip on myself. What was the point?

I guess it's not as bad as when a game series starts to intermingle with one another, just so you have to buy them all to get the complete package.

Log in to MaximumPC directly or log in using Facebook

Forgot your username or password?
Click here for help.

Login with Facebook
Log in using Facebook to share comments and articles easily with your Facebook feed.